The impact of external academic accreditation of undergraduate medical program on students’ satisfaction

Abstract

Background The external academic accreditation is a quality assurance and auditing process that focuses on the structure, process, and outcome of the education. It is an interrupting and highly demanding process in terms of effort, time, financial, and human resources. However, it is unclear in the literature how much of these external quality assurance practices impeded in the accreditation processes would reflect on the other end of the learning pathway, including student satisfaction. Methods A retrospective quantitative secondary data analysis, with a before-after comparison research design, was performed to evaluate external accreditation’s impact on students’ mean satisfaction score within two accreditation cycles at King Saud University (KSU)-Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS) program. Results The overall average students’ satisfaction scores pre-and-post the first accreditation cycle were 3.46/5 (±0.35), 3.71 (±0.39), respectively, with a P-value of < 0.001. The effect of post first accreditation cycle was sustainable for a couple of years, then maintained above the baseline of the pre-first accreditation cycle until the pre-second accreditation cycle. Similarly, the overall average students’ satisfaction scores pre-and-post the second accreditation cycles were 3.57/5 (±0.30) and 3.70 (±0.34), respectively, with a P-value of 0.04. Compared to the first accreditation cycle, the improvement of the mean score of students’ satisfaction rates was not sustained beyond the year corresponding to the post-second accreditation cycle. Conclusion Both accreditation cycles were associated with an increased score in students’ satisfaction. The preparatory phase activities and navigation through the self-study assessment while challenging the program’s competencies are essential triggers for quality improvement practices associated with accreditation.

Accreditation of medical education in Brazil: an evaluation of seventy-six medical schools

“…We chose to analyze domains considered important to the needs of Brazilian society and also the international literature (social accountability, integration with the health system, faculty development policies and environmental sustainability) [ 2 , 9 , 16 ]. We also presented detailed description of student’s domains, that we consider one of the stronger aspects of SAEME.…”

“…Medical schools must promote a healthy educational environment that is positive for learning and personal development [ 2 , 21 ]. This objective has been partially achieved by medical schools (Table 1 ).…”

Perceived Changes to Quality Assurance after AUN-QA Programme Assessment: Voices of Quality Assurance Practitioners, Academic Staff, and Students

“…It could promote systematic mapping of the curriculum and assessment strategies (Blouin et al, 2018). Assessing scaled students' satisfaction as an indirect measure of accreditation impact on medical programme in Saudi Arabia, Al-Eyadhy and Alenezi (2021) found that it has a positive impact on course conduction and practical/clinical experience. At the course level, another example is that the mission and objectives of the institution were incorporated into the course design (Hou et al, 2015).…”

Dental students’ satisfaction with their course and how it is associated to their satisfaction with life and career outlook

“…Emotional and social aspects are vital to the development and maintenance of interpersonal relations, including those between healthcare providers and patients 1 . The emotional reactions of university students are reflected by their academic satisfaction 2 . Students’ satisfaction with their undergraduate course may involve factors such as academic performance 4 , 5 , motivation in the choice of course 4 and job prospects 6 .…”