The combination of subsoil compaction and injudicious usage of nitrogenous fertilizers are key factors that may lower crop yields, especially in soils with a shallow hardpan. Therefore, the objective of this study was to determine the effects of tillage and N application on carinata productivity in rainfed conditions. A 3-year field study was conducted at the North Florida Research and Education Center, Quincy, FL, USA. Treatments were four rates of N (0, 45, 90, and 135 kg N ha −1 ) and three tillage methods (disking, chiseling, and no-tillage). Maximum cone index measurements for no-tillage occurred at 15 cm but at 20 cm soil depth for both chisel and disk tillage. A hardpan at 15 cm restricted taproot growth but promoted lateral root growth. Subsoiling and N application improved carinata growth relative to no-tillage. Seed yield response to N application rate depended on the tillage method. The agronomic maximum seed yield occurred at 134, 128, and 125 kg N ha −1 for chisel, disk, and no-tilled systems. Nitrogen agronomic efficiency was greatest at 45 kg N ha −1 for the chisel method and 95 kg N ha −1 for disk and no-tillage. Tillage has a greater potential to increase yields even at relatively low N levels. When tilled, carinata produces 8%-17% greater seed yield at 45 kg N ha −1 than no-tilled carinata grown with 135 kg N ha −1 . These results indicate that tilling the subsoil and applying 90-135 kg N ha −1 are required for carinata production in soils with a hardpan.