Highlights
•We assessed the predation deterrent Birdsbesafe® (BBS) in an Australian context.• Captures of birds and herpetofauna, but not mammals, fell when cats wore a BBS.• Rainbow coloured BBS were more effective than red or yellow. 20
•To date, the BBS is the only predation deterrent protecting herpetofauna.• The BBS is not suitable where pet cats predate endangered mammals.
25
AbstractMany pet cats hunt and, irrespective of whether or not this threatens wildlife populations, distressed owners may wish to curtail hunting while allowing their pets to roam. Therefore we evaluated the effectiveness of three patterned designs (simple descriptions being rainbow, red and yellow) of the anti-predation collar cover, the Birdsbesafe® (BBS), in reducing prey captures by 114 30 pet cats over 2 years in a suburban Australian context. The BBS offers a colourful indicator of a cat's presence and should therefore alert prey with good colour vision (birds and herpetofauna), but not most mammals with limited colour vision. We also interviewed the 82 owners of cats in the study about their experience using the BBS and their assessment of the behavioural responses of their cats. In the first year of the study, which focused on the effectiveness of different BBS colours, 35 captures of prey with good colour vision were reduced by 54% (95% CL 43% -64%) when cats were wearing a BBS of any colour, with the rainbow and red BBS more effective than the yellow when birds were prey. Captures of mammals were not reduced significantly. The second year assessed the rainbow BBS alone, and those data combined with rainbow data in the first year found a significant reduction of 47% (95% CL 43% -57%) in capture of prey with good colour vision, with no effect of 40 differences across years. We found no evidence that cats maintained a lower predation rate once Page 3 of 37 A c c e p t e d M a n u s c r i p t 3 the BBS was removed. Seventy-nine per cent of owners reported that their cats had no problems with the BBS and another 17% reported that their cats adjusted within 2 days. Fourteen owners reported that their cats spent more time at home and ate more while wearing the BBS. Two owners reported their cats stayed away from home more while wearing it. Sixty-four per cent of owners 45 using the red collar, 48% using rainbow and 46% using yellow believed that it worked. Overall, 77% of owners planned to continue using the BBS after the study had finished. The BBS is an option for owners wishing to reduce captures of birds and herpetofauna by free-ranging cats, especially where mammalian prey are introduced pests. To date, the BBS is the only predation deterrent that reduces significantly the number of herpetofauna brought home. It is unsuitable where endangered 50 mammalian prey or large invertebrates are vulnerable to predation by pet cats.