The Impact of General Strike on Government Healthcare Delivery in Kerala State in India

Abstract

General strike (also known as hartal) is used as a mode of protest by organizations and political parties in India. It is generally thought that hartals negatively impact the healthcare delivery in a society. We used the Right to Information Act to obtain data from government health centers in Kerala state in India for four hartal days (H-day) and two control days (A-day and B-day) for each H-day, from sixteen health centers including 6 Community Health Center (CHC), 6 Secondary Health Center (SHC), and 4 Tertiary Health Center (THC). Data on emergency room visits was available for six HCs. 15 HCs had a statistically significant decrease in the number of outpatient visits on H-day. There was no difference in the number of outpatient visits between the two control days (A and B) in 15 HCs, suggesting the lack of a posthartal surge in visits. Median decrease in outpatient visits in CHCs, SHCs, and THCs was 50.4%, 59.5%, and 47.4%, respectively. Hartal did not impact the number of emergency room visits in 6 out of 7 health centers assessed. Our study identified a significant harmful impact on government healthcare delivery due to hartals in Kerala. These findings have major public health implications.

Visiones de los actores claves sobre el proceso de acreditación de los Centros de Salud Familiar de la comuna de Concepción 2016

“…En la visión de las personas entrevistadas la paralización de labores de funcionarios públicos que repercute directamente en los principios de oportunidad y continuidad en la entrega de pres-taciones de salud. Las condiciones de movilización o huelga son una situación constante en el sector salud especialmente en los países de más bajos ingresos, y afecta el principio de continuidad y las garantías en el acceso y oportunidad 32,33 . Algunos estudios demuestran que se generan efectos en la cantidad de prestaciones que se otorgan durante estos períodos y, de manera específica, disminución de consultas y controles de atención primaria 34,35 .…”

Public Service Delivery in Turbulent Times Where Convergence Matters: Lessons from the Management of Covid-19 in Kerala

“…And all PHIs (except medical colleges and regional hospitals) are under the control of the respective tiers of the local government. A study conducted using secondary data for the period of 1991–2011 and primary data for 2011–2012 concluded that wherever there was a good relationship between elected representatives of local self-government and health personnel, the system of dual controls and responsibilities yielded good results, and, in most districts, the relationship was cordial and productive (Jacob, 2012; Jacob & Jacob, 2016).…”

On the forms, contributions and impacts of community mobilisation involved with Kerala’s COVID-19 response: Perspectives of health staff, Local Self Government institution and community leaders

“…LSGs have steered the coordination of efforts and activities by volunteers [24]. There is journalistic and anecdotal information suggesting that Kerala's COVID response included formal and informal mechanisms comprising a host of players including Kudumbashree (Kerala's government-run women's SHG program), voluntary organisations, youth associations as well as new formations like the Rapid Response Team (RRT) at the ward level set up during the pandemic [25]. RRTs were constituted formally by the state mechanism to have a supervised and monitored support for the state pandemic mitigation efforts [26].…”