The impact of host language proficiency across the immigrants’ earning distribution in Spain

Abstract

This paper explores the impact of Spanish language proficiency on immigrant earnings in Spain using an instrumental variable quantile regression approach. The impact is on average roughly 17.2% but varies substantially across the earning distribution. The return to destination language proficiency actually ranges from zero at the bottom quantiles to 30% at the top quantile of the earning distribution. These findings suggest that the benefits derived from host language knowledge are particularly important among individuals with stronger unobserved abilities and marketable skills and that language training policies targeted at specific immigrant population categories may be ineffective from a labor market earning perspective. JEL Classification: F22, J24, J61

Informality and the context of reception in South Africa's new immigrant destinations

“…The ability to communicate in the language of the host country has been found to raise immigrants' wages (Budría, de Ibarreta, & Swedberg, ; Gao & Smyth, ). A dummy variable therefore tests for the impact of fluency in Afrikaans.…”

Language Skills and Labor Market Performance of Immigrants in the Netherlands

“…Motivated by this identification strategy, Miranda and Zhu (2013b) study the language effects on immigrant-native wage gap in the UK by including male immigrants and male 4 natives in one sample. Budría and Swedberg (2012) and Di Paolo and Raymond (2012) use age at arrival together with other exogenous variables as instruments and find positive effects of Spanish proficiency and Catalan proficiency on earnings in Spain.…”

“…Australia (Chiswick and Miller, 1995), German in Germany (Dustmann, 1994;Dustmann andvan Soest, 2001, 2002), Hebrew in Israel (Chiswick, 1998) and Spanish and Catalan in Spain (Budría and Swedberg, 2012;Di Paolo and Raymond, 2012). Studies about language effects on labor market performance have to deal with several threats to identification.…”

Barriers of Culture, Networks, and Language in International Migration: A Review

“…Indeed, a frequently found result and widely accepted fact is that adult male immigrants with a fluent level in the local language earn a wage premium in the range from 5 % to 35 % (see, e.g., Carliner 1981, McManus et al 1983, Grenier 1984, Chiswick 1998, Chiswick, Miller 2002, Dustmann, Fabbri 2003, Budria, Swedberg 2012, Beckhusen et al 2013, Chiswick, Wang 2016. A unified methodology in most of the studies is to employ a human capital earnings function (Mincer 1974).…”