The Impact of Psychological Interventions with Elements of Mindfulness (PIM) on Empathy, Well-Being, and Reduction of Burnout in Physicians: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Introduction: Physician’s burnout has been recognized as an increasing and significant work-related syndrome, described by the combination of emotional exhaustion (EE) and depersonalization (D), together with low personal accomplishment (PA). It has many negative consequences on personal, organizational, and patient care levels. This systematic review aimed to analyze research articles where psychological interventions with elements of mindfulness (PIMs) were used to support physicians in order to reduce burnout and foster empathy and well-being. Methods: Systematic searches were conducted in May 2019, within six electronic databases PubMed, EBSCOhost MEDLINE, PsycArticles, Cochrane Library, JSTOR, and Slovenian national library information system. Different combinations of boolean operators were used—mindfulness, empathy, medicine/family medicine/general practice/primary care, burnout, doctors/physicians, intervention, and support group. Additional articles were manually searched from the reference list of the included articles. Studies with other healthcare professionals (not physicians and residents) and/or medical students, and those where PIMs were applied for educational or patient’s treatment purposes were excluded. Results: Of 1194 studies identified, 786 screened and 139 assessed for eligibility, there were 18 studies included in this review. Regardless of a specific type of PIMs applied, results, in general, demonstrate a positive impact on empathy, well-being, and reduction in burnout in participating physicians. Compared with other recent systematic reviews, this is unique due to a broader selection of psychological interventions and emphasis on a sustained effect measurement. Conclusions: Given the pandemic of COVID-19, it is of utmost importance that this review includes also interventions based on modern information technologies (mobile apps) and can be used as an awareness-raising material for physicians providing information about feasible and easily accessible interventions for effective burnout prevention and/or reduction. Future research should upgrade self-reported data with objective psychological measures and address the question of which intervention offers more benefits to physicians.

The impact of mindfulness practice on physician burnout: A scoping review

“… Li et al (2020) listed a growing body of research on general negative impacts that COVID-19 posed on mental health but they highlighted that this academic literature mostly fell between the two camps of being either commentaries or cross-sectional studies. Linking the expanded requirement for mindfulness to COVID-19, whilst relying on pre-COVID research, is consistent with other laudable work which also acknowledges that the bona fide research prior to 2019 has relevance to the pandemic and post-pandemic era ( Tement et al, 2021 ; Marotta et al, 2022 ; Sampei et al, 2022 ). These writings also tacitly acknowledge the paucity of published work in the last 3 years that provide concurrent academic sources.…”

Mindfulness Coaching with Digital Lifestyle Monitoring Enhances Selective Attention in Medical Scientists

“…The COVID19 pandemic exacerbated distress in healthcare workers and has been associated with dropout from training and reduction of work hours 11,12 , which ultimately impacts on the entire healthcare system. Hence, a need exists for interventions that can help promote well-being, especially for individuals training as medical scientists 13 .…”

Alleviating learning burnout of Chinese middle school students by school‐based mindfulness training: The mediating role of psychological resilience

“…Mindfulness skill refers to “paying attention in a specific way: intentional, present, and nonjudgmental” (Kabat‐Zinn, 2013), involving three related psychological skills: (a) deliberately focusing on the present (rather than letting the brain ruminate on the past or worry about the future); (b) perception of the situation and participation in clear conscious actions (not emotionally, automatically, or unconsciously); (c) experience every moment without bias to emotional reactions or psychological judgments (e.g., expectations, wishes or fears that may or may not be related to what happened) (Roeser et al, 2013). The mindfulness‐based intervention has been proven to alleviate the job burnout of medical staff, teachers, counselors, and other professionals (Luken & Sammons, 2016; Ramachandran et al, 2022; Tement et al, 2021), as well as students' learning burnout (Li et al, 2020; Wan, 2020). It was explained that, through mindfulness training, dispositional mindfulness, and psychological resilience could be improved simultaneously.…”