The impact of social unrest and pandemic on mental health of young people in Hong Kong: The transdiagnostic role of event-based rumination

Abstract

Objective: Co-occurring population-level events, such as social unrest and coronavirus disease 2019, are observed in many societies today. Few studies have explored their combined mental health effects on young people. While self-focused rumination has been suggested to be a key mechanism underlying depression, the role of event-based rumination in mediating the impact of population stressors has yet to be elucidated. Methods: Data were collected from 6988 young people in a large-scale community online survey in Hong Kong. The survey assessed symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder and depression, direct exposure to social unrest-related traumatic events, coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic-related events, personal stressful life events, event-based rumination and other individual risk factors. Results: High levels of comorbid post-traumatic stress disorder and depressive symptoms were observed. Logistic regression analysis revealed that probable post-traumatic stress disorder was associated with traumatic events (odds ratio = 1.73, 95% confidence interval = [1.64, 1.82]), pandemic-related events (odds ratio = 1.08, confidence interval = [1.01, 1.16]), stressful life events (odds ratio = 1.20, confidence interval = [1.21, 1.37]), high event-based rumination (odds ratio = 3.00, confidence interval = [2.58, 3.48]), lower resilience (odds ratio = 1.18, confidence interval = [1.15, 1.21]), higher smartphone reliance (odds ratio = 1.09, confidence interval = [1.05, 1.13]) and financial concerns (odds ratio = 1.25, confidence interval = [1.18, 1.33]). The odds for probable post-traumatic stress disorder was also significantly higher when two or more traumatic events were experienced (odds ratio = 4.03, confidence interval = [3.52, 4.62]). Factors associated with moderate-to-severe level depressive symptoms were similar. Event-based rumination significantly mediated between different types of external events (traumatic events, pandemic-related events, stressful life events) and both post-traumatic stress disorder and depressive symptoms. Conclusion: These findings suggest that diverse types of stressful events during population-level crises could add to personal stressors to affect mental health outcomes in young people. Among other protective and risk factors, event-based rumination presented as a prominent transdiagnostic mediator for different symptom dimensions which may be a potentially important target for early risk detection and intervention.

Excessive fear of clusters of holes, its interaction with stressful life events and the association with anxiety and depressive symptoms: large epidemiological study of young people in Hong Kong

“…24 The scale and its subscales have been validated and used in Chinese community and youth samples. 22,[25][26][27] DASS-A, DASS-D and DASS-S also showed good internal consistency in this study (α = 0.82-0.87).…”

Significance of timely responses to mental health crises during unprecedented societal and global changes using an agile, empathic and user-centred digital approach: lessons from the Hong Kong experience

“…With preparatory qualitative interviews conducted with different stakeholders (including those arrested, psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers and those not in the mental health field), in-depth exploration of the different perspectives and sentiments on local forums and social media platforms, and feedback gathered concerning user experience over an intensive 3-week period, we developed and launched the ‘Flow Tool’ 10–13…”

“…Since its launch in February 2020—a few weeks after the social unrest and local outbreak of COVID-19, the Tool has accumulated 20 740 responses in just 2 weeks, with 10 110 completing the full version of the tool 11. More than 70 000 responses have since been recorded.…”

“…The ability to engage such a large number of users even at a time of overwhelming distress and distrust—half of which being under the age of 25, suggests some uniqueness about the tool that made it appealing. Indeed, such a design could introduce some bias to the data: we did engage a group of individuals with above-average symptoms of depression and PTSD 10 11. Nevertheless, this also highlights the ability of the tool in engaging a more ‘vulnerable’ group who may otherwise not engage in traditional research and services.…”

Adventure-Based Cognitive Behavioral Intervention for Hong Kong University Students: A Randomized Controlled Study

“…In Hong Kong, Lun et al (2018) found high prevalence of depressive (68.5%) and anxiety (54.4%) symptoms. Additionally, recent social unrest and COVID-19 pandemic since 2019 have been reported to lead to increasing levels of post-traumatic stress symptoms (41.8%), depressive symptoms (78.9%), and loneliness feelings (47.7%) among young people in Hong Kong, indicating a peaked mental health deterioration and an unprecedented mental health service needs (Hong Kong Federation of Youth Groups, 2021; Wong et al, 2022). However, university counseling services in Hong Kong is insufficient.…”