The impact of socio-economic background on satisfaction: evidence for policy-makers

Abstract

Consumer satisfaction with utility services has received increased attention from firms, consumer associations, regulators and governments since the 1990s. Evidence is mounting that consumers in specific socioeconomic groups express lower satisfaction levels than their peers, at least, in some utility markets. Seeing this as part of their remit to protect consumer welfare, governments and international organizations are exploring possible demand-side policy responses with the intention of ameliorating lower satisfaction levels of these groups of consumers. However, more information on the precise relationships between satisfaction and consumers' socioeconomic background is required if policy is to be proportional and effective. This paper provides new empirical knowledge on this topic by contrasting consumers' stated and revealed preferences for five utility services (electricity, gas, fixed and cellular telephony and Internet) across twelve European countries. We find strong evidence that consumers' socioeconomic characteristics matter: consumers with lower levels of education, the elderly and those not employed exhibit particular expenditure patterns on, and lower satisfaction levels with, some utility services. However, this relationship is uneven and depends on the socioeconomic category and service in question. We conclude by highlighting five findings which may be of use to policy-makers when considering whether demand-side regulatory policies are required

Citizen Assessment as Policy Tool of Urban Public Services: Empirical Evidence from Assessments of Urban Green Spaces in China

“…Aside from the effect of a general perception of insufficient UGSs in the dense city, UGSs are free public services and their use induces almost no expenses. This is remarkably different from those (utility) services required to choose and pay in the market, such as water, electricity, and gas [13]. Namely, UGSs may be more accessible than these services.…”

“…This relation is associated with the specific services examined [51]. Likewise, a latest study observed that the socio-economic effects on satisfaction are complex, depending on particular (utility) services [13]. The detachment between personal backgrounds and the overall assessment implies that citizen assessments mainly depended on the actual status of the UGSs themselves, thus indicating the validity of citizen assessments.…”

Institutional reforms to integrate regulation and competition policy: Economic analysis, international perspectives, and the case of the CNMC in Spain

“…In practice this principle, which some authors refer to as "paternalism" (Thaler andSunstein, 2003, andCamerer et al, 2003), would require, for instance, that service providers present their bills in simple and transparent terms, easily understandable to every consumer (example taken from Clifton et al, 2014) or to streamline the procedures for post-sale and quality-service claims. Given the nature of these interventions, which require extensive knowledge of the product or service market, regulators are optimally placed to undertake them.…”

“…Economic analysis provides sound reasons to support these consumer-oriented shifts in the remit of the regulators (see Clifton et al 2014).…”

Efficiency and Sustainability of Local Public Goods and Services. Case Study for Romania

“…Public services should be provided to all citizens, regardless of their socio-economic differences [10]. However, the same authors proved one year before that more vulnerable citizens are less satisfied than their peers in regard to the public services provided to them by national and local government [11].…”