Comparison with artificial galaxy models is essential for translating the incomplete and low signal-to-noise data we can obtain on astrophysical stellar populations to physical interpretations which describe their composition, physical properties, histories and internal conditions. In particular, this is true for distant galaxies, whose unresolved light embeds clues to their formation and evolution as well as their impact on their wider environs. Stellar population synthesis models are now used as the foundation of analysis at all redshifts, but are not without their problems. Here we review the use of stellar population synthesis models, with a focus on applications in the distant Universe.Galaxies 2020, 8, 6 2 of 32 astronomical observations, usually over a wider wavelength range or with a higher signal-to-noise, to break.In the photon-starved regime occupied by observations of the earliest galaxies to radiate through the Universe, this presents a problem: often it simply is not possible to find an independent diagnostic which will distinguish between models, and obtainable signal-to-noise may be limited by instrumental and background noise rather than by the source. In this situation, the interpretation offered by a single population synthesis model is often accepted without close scrutiny, with a deep faith placed on the calibration of those models in the relatively local Universe. In the past, for observations of galaxies at z < 2, this faith has been well founded. The stellar populations which can be resolved in detail and probed in the Milky Way and the Local Group are typical of galaxies at these redshifts in both age and metallicity. However as the observational frontier is pushed back to ever higher redshifts, it is clear that the typical star formation densities and environments are very different, as are the stellar metallicities [10, and references therein]. This has prompted a reevaluation of the stellar population synthesis models in use at these redshifts, and their calibration in hitherto unconsidered regimes [11].This review discusses both our current state of understanding of galaxies in the distant Universe, and how that understanding is informed by the stellar population synthesis models we use. Key examples and uncertainties are highlighted, and a holistic approach, in which all possible diagnostic indicators of a stellar population are considered, is advocated.
Galaxies in the Distant Universe
The First StarsThe definition of the distant Universe varies, but in the context of galaxy formation and evolution it applies primarily to the interval between the formation of the first stars ('cosmic dawn') which ended the cosmic Dark Ages at around z ∼ 7 − 15, and the coincident peaks of the volume-averaged star formation rate density history and AGN activity at z ∼ 2 ('cosmic noon'). Over this ∼2.5 Gyr interval, the first galaxies were not only born, but also evolved significantly [e.g. 12,13], such that galaxy populations at z > 5 are typically younger, more highly ionizing, less massive and less...