The impact of within-industry diversification on firm performance

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate how within-industry diversification affects the financial performance of small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in emerging markets (EMs). The authors draw on both the resource-based view and the institutional perspective and argue that within-industry diversification can enhance the financial performance of SMEs in EMs. Due to institutional voids in emerging economies, SMEs can gain additional benefits from scope economies, as well as from market returns, by filling product market voids and gaps in business ecosystems, while also enjoying low input and labor costs that reduce the coordination costs of diversification. This, in turn, enhances benefits of within-industry diversification, thereby resulting in higher financial profitability. Design/methodology/approach This study employs panel data econometrics to estimate the model. The authors test hypotheses on 195 firms, originating from five countries in Southeast Asia, during the period of 2009–2014. Findings The empirical results support the arguments. Within-industry diversification has a positive impact on the performance of SMEs in EMs. These effects become weaker when the institutional contexts are more developed. Nevertheless, such effects become stronger when SMEs in EMs are more efficient. Research limitations/implications The relationship between within-industry diversification and performance is a positive linear pattern, which differs from the pattern in advanced economies. In addition to unrelated diversification, the related diversification is preferable for firms in EMs. Practical implications The paper provides implications for SMEs that aim to enhance their performance by engaging in single product lines and within-industry diversification. Originality/value This paper examines the different ways within-industry diversification can enhance SMEs performance in EM contexts.

The role of internal and external sources of knowledge on frugal innovation: moderating role of innovation capabilities

“…One the basis of the above discussion, we derived the perfect model given below (Figure 1). (Pangboonyanon and Kalasin, 2018). Similarly, small firms are always supported by the government because their performance leads to the overall emerging market (Manex et al, 2018).…”

EMS Application in Businesses – Systematic Review

“…It should be pointed out that EMSs are applied as part of a set of administrative instruments to manage effects in order to encourage enterprises to upgrade their environmental and in general "green" practices. Besides the EMS application with small and medium size enterprises may aid them in the implementation of environmental standards and, under most circumstances, adhere to the standards of ISO 14001 (Pangboonyanon & Kalasin, 2018).…”

Challenges and Opportunities of Building Resilient MSMEs in Zambia

“…BCM should form part of the wider enterprise risk management. BCM is concerned with the maintenance of crucial business deliverables of an Portfolio: MSMEs often face the challenge of choosing between either focusing on the current product line, or diversifying their business portfolio through the introduction of multiple new product offerings within the same industry in order to enhance their financial performance (Pangboonyanon & Kalasia, 2018). It is common, however, for most MSMEs to concentrate operations on a multiple range of products within their core industry since they lack adequate resources to develop a suitable diversification strategy for venturing into a new or unrelated industry (Lynn & Reinsch, 1990;Colombo et al, 2014;Hashai, 2015).…”

“…According to Hashai (2015), "within-industry diversification may permit firms to leverage specific knowledge on technologies, the firm's customer base, its sales and distribution facilities or its experience with existing products, to enhance their performance as well as penetrate additional product categories within their core industry." It allows MSMEs to focus on developing and taking advantage of their competences in their core industries, whilst at the same time enabling MSMEs to benefit from scope economies, which results in enhanced performance and a competitive advantage for the MSME (Pangboonyanon and Kalasia, 2018). Despite the benefits associated with the within-industry diversification strategy, there is a downside to the strategy.…”