The Impending Dilemma of Electrocardiogram Screening in Athletic Children

Abstract

Sudden cardiac death (SCD) affects 2/100,000 young, active athletes per year of which 40% are less than 18 years old. In 2004, the International Olympic Committee accepted the Lausanne Recommendations, including a 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG), as a pre-participation screening tool for adult Olympic athletes. The debate on extending those recommendations to the pediatric population has recently begun. The aims of our study were to highlight the characteristics of the young athlete ECG, phenotypical manifestations of SCD-related disease in children, and challenges of implanting ECG screening in athletic children. A systematic review of the literature is performed. We searched available electronic medical databases for articles relevant to SCD, ECG, silent cardiac diseases, and athletic children. We focused on ECG screening and description in a pediatric population. We identified 2240 studies. Sixty-two relevant articles and one book were selected. In children, prepubertal ECG and the ECG phenotype of most SCD-related diseases differ notably from adults. The characteristics of the prepubertal ECG and of the phenotypical manifestation of SCD-related disease in children will result in less specific and less sensitive ECG-based screening programs. Those limitations advise against extending the adult recommendation to children, without further studies. Until then, history and physical exam should remain the cornerstone of screening for SCD-related pathologies in children.

Protecting the stars of tomorrow: do international cardiovascular preparticipation screening policies account for the paediatric athlete? A systematic review and quality appraisal

“…In addition, to ensure diagnostic accuracy for this age group, age-specific normative values and tailored approaches to disease management are also needed 8 40. One such consideration is that of biological maturation.…”

Promoting Judicious Primary Care Referral of Patients with Chest Pain to Cardiology: A Quality Improvement Initiative

“…Proponents would argue that this is a perfect example of why ECG should be done for all children regardless of symptoms. 28 On the other hand, the American Heart Association (AHA) recommends a 14-item check list when evaluating children for ECG screening. Only those with a concern are to be referred for an ECG.…”

Electrocardiogram in Pediatric Syncope

“…The clinical relevance of borderline ECG findings in the pediatric population is a common cause of confusion among physicians considering that significant physiologic ECG changes are seen throughout childhood, particularly in neonates, at onset of puberty, and in athletes. 16 The definition of normal QTc values becomes of particular importance when trying to rule out long QT syndrome (LQTS) as an arrhythmogenic cause for pediatric syncope. Corrected QT values in the range of 440 to 470 milliseconds are commonly labeled as "borderline," whereas the 99th centile for normal QTc values is >470 milliseconds in males and >480 milliseconds in females.…”