The Implications of Temporary Jobs on the Distribution of Wages in Italy: An Unconditional IVQTE Approach

Abstract

Using Italian data, this paper investigates the wage implications of temporary jobs across the whole pay profile using unconditional quantile regression (UQR) models. Results clearly indicate that the wage penalty associated to temporary jobs is significantly larger at the bottom of wage profile and is almost absent for high-wage jobs. This is in line with the sticky floors hypothesis, supporting the idea that the wage gap for temporary employees depends on their position in the wage distribution for low-paid jobs. To recover a causal interpretation, I employ an instrumental variable (IV) strategy. I adopt the unconditional instrumental variable quantile treatment effects (IVQTE) estimator proposed by Frolich and Melly, which corrects for endogenous selection in temporary contracts. The IVQTE estimates yield similar results to standard UQR, even if the wage penalty is larger in size at the bottom of the wage distribution and disappears at the top quantiles. This evidence highlights that policies aimed at increasing flexibility may reinforce the two-tier nature of the Italian labour market and the relative wage inequality.I would like to thank Marco Leonardi, Blaise Melly, Matteo Picchio, Massimiliano Bratti, Fabio Parisi, and two anonymous referees for useful comments and suggestions.

The Structure of the Wage Gap for Temporary Workers: Evidence from Australian Panel Data

“…A major shortcoming of previous Australian studies is that they are focussed on the mean of the wage distribution. Evidence from other countries, however, tells us that the wage effects of temporary employment may differ between low‐ and high‐paid workers (Bosio , ; Comi and Grasseni ; Mertens et al. ; Mertens and McGinnity ; Santangelo ).…”

Wage Penalty for Temporary Workers in Turkey: Evidence From Quantile Regressions

“…It has also been used in several other studies examining wage gaps in Italian labor markets (Picchio 2006;Bosio 2014). γ vector includes variables looking at job search while being employed that are not part of the wage equation.…”

“…This variable is constructed with the idea that employed temporary workers are more likely to be searching for jobs in comparison to employed permanent workers. It has also been used in several other studies examining wage gaps in Italian labor markets (Picchio 2006;Bosio 2014). In the second step, we calculate the inverse Mill's ratio from the above equation and use it as a variable in equation (1).…”

“…Depending on the country, sticky floor and glass ceiling are both observed in the empirical literature. For example, it has been found that the price differential is less at the upper end of the distribution in Italy (Bosio 2014). The limited number of studies on developing countries have generated varied results in terms of the effect of contract types on wages along distribution.…”

Short Notice, Big Difference? The Effect of Temporary Employment on Firm Competitiveness across Sectors

“…Empirical results typically document a significant wage gap between employees with FTCs and permanent contracts (PCs). This gap has been attributed to substantial heterogeneity across jobs and/or individuals (Bosio 2014;Brown and Sessions 2003;Comi and Grasseni 2012;De la Rica 2004). Yet a significant fraction remains unexplained after controlling for observable heterogeneity.…”