The importance of being a lumen

Abstract

Advances in tissue engineering and microtechnology have enabled researchers to more easily generate in vitro tissue models that mimic the tissue geometry and spatial organization found in vivo (e.g., vessel or mammary duct models with tubular structures). However, the widespread adoption of these models for biological studies has been slow, in part due to the lack of direct comparisons between existing 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional cell culture models and new organotypic models that better replicate tissue structure. Using previously developed vessel and mammary duct models with 3-dimensional lumen structures, we have begun to explore this question. In a direct comparison between these next generation organotypic models and more traditional methods, we observed differences in the levels of several secreted growth factors and cytokines. In addition, endothelial vessel geometry profoundly affects the phenotypic behavior of carcinoma cells, suggesting that more traditional in vitro assays may not capture in vivo events. Here, we seek to review and add to the increasing evidence supporting the hypothesis that using cell culture models with more relevant tissue structure influences cell fate and behavior, potentially increasing the relevance of biological findings.-Bischel, L. L., Sung, K. E., Jiménez-Torres, J. A., Mader, B., Keely, P. J., Beebe, D. J. The importance of being a lumen. FASEB J. 28, 4583-4590 (2014). www.fasebj.org Key Words: tissue engineering ⅐ cell culture ⅐ tissue geometry ⅐ microtechnology ⅐ microfluidics Current research tools for the study of cell-or tissue-level biological processes can be classified along a continuum of increasingly more complex models, ranging from 2-dimensional (2D) cell culture to in vivo animal models (Fig. 1). In vivo models involve the use of whole organisms, usually mice, which inherently account for many important complexities in the body (1-3). However, it is difficult to investigate the role of the many microenvironmental factors individually using in vivo models, due to challenges associated with isolating specific interactions. In addition, in vivo models tend to be time consuming and costly, limiting their use in routine assays. Moreover, the use of animal models comes with ethical issues, and, in many cases, animal biology is significantly different from humans. At the other end of the spectrum, in vitro 2D cell culture is commonly used to study specific cell behavior and interactions. While these assays have provided much scientific knowledge and insight, they typically lack numerous factors associated with complex microenvironments, including tissue structure, cell-cell interactions, or cell-extracellular matrix (ECM) interactions, raising questions regarding the relevance of 2D cell culture for modeling in vivo responses.To bridge this gap between in vivo and in vitro models and augment the tools available to biologists, there has been an increasing interest in the development of biomimetic tissue models with improved representation of in vivo condi...

LumeNEXT: A Practical Method to Pattern Luminal Structures in ECM Gels

“…This may be due to concentration gradients of soluble factors, cell adhesion, and mechanical forces . Similarly, we have observed a considerable change in cytokine secretion by both endothelial cells and epithelial cells when cultured in an in vivo‐like structure (i.e., a lumen) compared to 2D and 3D cultures . Lumens (i.e., tubular structures) are ubiquitous in vivo being present in blood vessels, mammary ducts, and the lymphatic system.…”

An Accessible Organotypic Microvessel Model Using iPSC‐Derived Endothelium

“…Organotypic design is more than cosmetic: the importance of cell–cell interactions and structure/function relationships is well established . It has even been demonstrated that structure and geometry alone alters endothelial and epithelial cell soluble factor signaling and phenotype . In the study of the innate immune response, for example, it has been shown that multiculture, cell–cell signaling, and cell–matrix interactions alter neutrophil transendothelial migration, chemotaxis behavior, and surface marker expression .…”

Recapitulating the Vasculature Using Organ-On-Chip Technology

“…Misalignment and seams will lead to discontinuities in the wall, disturbing the flow and adhesion of endothelium. The layer-by-layer fabrication also results in predominantly square shaped channels that do not resemble the in vivo round lumen shape that is critical for normal functioning [52]. Either high resolution techniques are required to create round channels on the micrometre scale of the vasculature or post processing must be applied to reshape the square channels into round ones.…”