The importance of being informed: Experimental evidence on demand for environmental quality

Abstract

To what extent does information affect the demand for environmental quality? A randomly selected group of households in an Indian city were informed whether or not their drinking water had tested positive for fecal contamination using a simple, inexpensive test kit. Households initially not purifying their water and told that their drinking water was possibly contaminated, were 11 percentage points more likely to begin some form of home purification in the next 8 weeks than households that received no information. They spent $7.24 (at PPP) more on purification than control households. By way of comparison, an additional year of schooling of the most educated male in the household is associated with a 3 percentage-point rise in the probability of initial purification, while a standard-deviation increase in the wealth index is associated with a 12 percentage-point rise in this probability and an $11.75 rise in expenditure. Initially purifying households that received a "no contamination" result did not react by reducing purification. These results suggest that estimates of the demand for environment quality that assume full information may signficantly under-estimate it.

Location, Location, Location: Residence, Wealth, And The Quality Of Medical Care In Delhi, India

“…Some optimism is warranted, because there are precedents that people do respond to specific information aimed at particular practices. 19 The allocation of more-competent public doctors to clinics in poorer neighborhoods could improve matters via the "spillover effect" in which differences between rich and poor within neighborhoods and levels of facilities are small. One of the fundamental premises on which the public system of curative health care is based is that of ensuring equity: The public sector should balance out inequalities arising from the location choices of the private sector.…”

Reports of Water Quality Violations Induce Consumers to Buy Bottled Water

“…Madajewicz et al [2007] tested the water in each of 6,500 wells across Bangladesh; they then labeled each well as safe or unsafe and reported the result to the users of the well: people with labeled unsafe wells are over four times as likely to change to another well within one year. Jalan and Somanathan [2008] selected households in an Indian city, informed people whether their drinking water had tested positive for fecal contaminant. Non-purifying households who learned that their water is "dirty" are 11 percentage points more likely to change their averting behavior than households who received no information.…”

Education and the Political Economy of Environmental Protection

“…This kind of conclusion may be related with some experimental studies dealing with the education, the information about environmental risks, or environmental protection. (see, for instance, Jalan & Somanathan (2008)) …”