“…Sulfur isotope fractionation during sulfate reduction is negatively correlated with sulfate concentration, exhibiting a small fractionation when sulfate concentration is less than 1 mM (Canfield & Raiswell, ; Habicht, Gade, Thamdrup, Berg, & Canfield, ). In the AOM zone, deeper in the subsurface, pore water sulfate can be largely consumed by the methane flux (Kaplan & Rittenberg, ; Wehrmann et al, ), leading to 34 S enriched pyrites in this zone (Jørgensen, Böttcher, Lüschen, Neretin, & Volkov, ; Lash, , ; Wehrmann et al, ). The relatively light values at Tianfengping suggest that concretion growth occurred early, at a shallow depth, prior to the development of the closed‐system conditions that favor methanogenesis (Canfield et al, ; Pallud & van Cappellen, ; Thamdrup & Canfield, ).…”