In the present aggressive world of competition, corporate social responsibility (CSR) strategies are becoming important weapons for organizations to perform well and achieve their goals. In this respect, organizations need to assess their CSR performance and improve their actions for a more genuine approach. We present an insightful framework to explain the effectiveness of CSR strategies by proposing four dimensions- weak versus strong, narrow versus broad, strategic versus genuine, and public relation (PR) profile versus no public relation (PR) profile. The proposed framework can be used to assess organizational CSR performance and as a decision tool for the CSR practices that should be improved especially in the wake of the Coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. The framework will also help devise ways and means to assist the nation to combat the repercussions of the slowdown and mitigate the after-effects of the pandemic by evaluating current CSR practices. Based on the proposed tool, a model of CSR management for genuine social change was developed to help organizations define its best practices and improve CSR actions.