The influence of market orientation on firm performance and members’ livelihood in Ethiopian seed producer cooperatives

Abstract

The positive effects of market orientation and its components on firm performance are empirically supported by studies conducted for large firms in developed economies. However, its influence on performance in developing and emerging (D&E) economies, particularly under a cooperative's context, has been under-researched. This paper examines the impact of market orientation components on the performance of seed producer cooperatives (SPCs) in Ethiopia. Results show that customer orientation, interfunctional coordination, and supplier orientation, but not competitor orientation, contribute to higher business performance. Our findings confirm that customer orientation is the key factor for superior business performance in D&E economies. Business performance has a mediating effect between market orientation components and livelihood performance. Interfunctional coordination and supplier orientation influence the livelihood of member farmers both directly and indirectly via business performance. The study concludes that market orientation of SPCs is very important for business performance and provides a strong basis for the livelihood of seed producer families. SPCs can improve their performance and the livelihood of member-farmer families by implementing market oriented strategies, emphasising the key components of market orientation.

A Study on the Determinants of Financial Performance of U.S. Agricultural Cooperatives

“…three times to its member associated and creating jobs for more than hundred million (International Labor Organization, 2014). Cooperatives to become competitive in the markets do not adopt sheer profiteering but, run on values that make it competitive and strong enough to beat the market peculiarities and to sustain for a longer period (Sisay, Verhees, & Van Trijp, 2017). A broad set of values among cooperative enterprises consist of features like democracy, equality, responsibility, equity, and self-help, etc.…”

Harnessing a ‘Currency Matrix’ for Performance Measurement in Cooperatives: A Multi-Phased Study

“…SBA measurement is often favored when objective data is difficult to obtain or insufficiently reliable [108]. SBA metrics facilitate the assessment of complex issues (e.g., expert's view on member satisfaction) [110,112] as well as that of non-financial or non-market aspects [60,109]. Moreover, SBA measurement enables cross-sectional analysis through sectors and markets in general, as performance can be quantified in comparison to objectives or competitors [38,107].…”

“…Finally, SMA measures alone cannot address the dual objective nature of the cooperative organization, as they do not account for the latter's performance as an entity. Members' benefits are naturally conditioned by the cooperative's achievements [112], so SMA metrics might mainly be reflecting rather than assessing organizational performance.…”

The impact of brand equity on the financial performance of marketing cooperatives

“…As user‐owned and user‐controlled business organizations, farmer cooperatives do not often possess a market orientation (Beverland, ; Challita, Aurier, & Sentis, 2018; Grashuis, ; Grashuis & Magnier, ; Hardesty, ; Kontogeorgos, ). Instead, the strategic orientation of most farmer cooperatives is toward the objectives and preferences of its users, which is problematic as cooperative performance is more likely to be impacted by strategic characteristics as opposed to ownership or governance characteristics (Benos, Kalogeras, Verhees, Sergaki, & Pennings, ; Kyriakopoulos, Meulenberg, & Nilsson, ; Sisay, Verhees, & van Trijp, ).…”