The Influence of Masculine Norms and Occupational Factors on Mental Health: Evidence From the Baseline of the Australian Longitudinal Study on Male Health

Abstract

Men employed in male-dominated occupations are at elevated risk of work-related fatalities, injuries, and suicide. Prior research has focused on associations between psychosocial and physical exposures at work and health outcomes. However, masculine norms may also contribute to mental health. We used data from the baseline survey of the Australian Longitudinal Study on Male Health to examine whether: (a) men in male-dominated jobs report greater adherence to masculine norms; (b) being in a male-dominated occupation is associated with poorer mental health; and (c) being in a male-dominated occupation modifies the association between masculine norms and mental health. Masculine norms were measured using the Conformity to Masculine Norms Inventory (CMNI-22). Mental health was assessed using the SF-12. Results of regression analysis (adjusted for covariates) suggest a linear relationship between the extent to which an occupation is male-dominated and endorsement of values on the CMNI-22. Many CMNI-22 subscales were related to poorer mental health. However, the need for self-reliance was identified as the strongest predictor of poorer mental health. The mental health scale did not appear to be patterned by occupational gender composition and we did not find an interaction between the gender ratio of an occupation and the CNMI-22 scale. These findings highlight the need to address harmful aspects of masculinity as a potential cause of mental health problems. More longitudinal research is needed on the social domains in which gender and health are experienced, such as in the workplace.

Are Young Men Getting the Message? Age Differences in Suicide Prevention Literacy among Male Construction Workers

“…It is possible that the reduced endorsement of the workplace as having some responsibility to address mental health that we observed among males aged 35 and older may reflect the enactment of masculine norms (which similarly may be either a cohort effect or an industry effect). The construction industry is known to be a key setting in which hegemonic masculinities remain inveterate [28]. Masculine ideals are founded on toughness, control, autonomy and competence [29]: help-seeking and admitting a need for help violate these standards.…”

Men’s work, women’s work and suicide: a retrospective mortality study in Australia

“…As mentioned above, recent research 9 suggests that men in male‐dominated occupations are also much less likely to seek treatment compared to non‐male‐dominated occupations. There is also research suggesting that males in male‐dominated occupations are more likely to endorse male gender norms such as self‐reliance 35 and stigma in relation to mental health problems, which have been shown to be risk factors for suicide 36 . Alcohol and drug use, which are recognised risk factors for suicide, are thought to be higher in many male‐dominated occupations 10 …”

Treatment-seeking differences for mental health problems in male- and non-male-dominated occupations: evidence from the HILDA cohort

“…Accompanying this, environmental influences in male-dominated occupations may reinforce negative attitudes towards help-seeking, resulting in a lower overall likelihood of a male attending mental health services. A recent paper we conducted (Milner et al ., 2018a) demonstrates that men in male-dominated occupations are more likely to adhere to traditional masculine norms regarding emotional control and self-reliance. These aspects of masculinity are thought to be associated with poorer help-seeking (Galdas et al ., 2005).…”