The influence of mobility among high-risk populations on HIV transmission in Western Kenya

Abstract

Western Kenya suffers a highly endemic and also very heterogeneous epidemic of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Although female sex workers (FSW) and their male clients are known to be at high risk for HIV, HIV prevalence across regions in Western Kenya is not strongly correlated with the fraction of women engaged in commercial sex. An agent-based network model of HIV transmission, geographically stratified at the county level, was fit to the HIV epidemic, scale-up of interventions, and populations of FSW in Western Kenya under two assumptions about the potential mobility of FSW clients. In the first, all clients were assumed to be resident in the same geographies as their interactions with FSW. In the second, some clients were considered non-resident and engaged only in interactions with FSW, but not in longer-term non-FSW partnerships in these geographies. Under both assumptions, the model successfully reconciled disparate geographic patterns of FSW and HIV prevalence. Transmission patterns in the model suggest a greater role for FSW in local transmission when clients were resident to the counties, with 30.0% of local HIV transmissions attributable to current and former FSW and clients, compared to 21.9% when mobility of clients was included. Nonetheless, the overall epidemic drivers remained similar, with risky behavior in the general population dominating transmission in high-prevalence counties. Our modeling suggests that co-location of high-risk populations and generalized epidemics can further amplify the spread of HIV, but that large numbers of formal FSW and clients are not required to observe or mechanistically explain high HIV prevalence in the general population.

The future of a partially effective HIV vaccine: assessing limitations at the population level

“…Another limitation stems from the fact that in South Africa, the HIV epidemic is highly heterogeneous between provinces, mostly differing in prevalence of male circumcision and non-marital relationships (Johnson et al 2017a). In this context, national-level models (such as the present study) must be utilized with caution; e.g., it has been shown that spatial heterogeneity and associated migration strongly influence HIV transmission (Bershteyn et al 2018; Dobra et al 2017; Coffee et al 2007; Voeten et al 2009) and therefore vaccination implementation. Considering constrained vaccine coverage regarding heterogeneously distributed geospatial and behavioral risk would raise ethical questions of how to devise vaccine rollout in an optimal way (Keeling and Shattock 2012).…”

Flower sharing and pollinator health: a behavioural perspective

“…[116,117]), and IBMs are being used more frequently to understand disease epidemiology (e.g. [118,119]).…”

Understanding the Evolving Role of Voluntary Medical Male Circumcision as a Public Health Strategy in Eastern and Southern Africa: Opportunities and Challenges

“…In an analysis of 14 ESA priority countries, Kripke et al found that costs per infection averted ranged from US$1300 to $22,000 [ 65 ••]. The variability was driven more by the wide differences in HIV incidence across ESA settings [ 13 , 81 – 83 ] (Fig. 1 a) than by differences in unit costs of VMMC (Fig.…”