A fixture hardening process for aerospace gear box components of alloy S156 (16NiCrMo16-5, 1.6722) is investigated by thermomechanical metallurgical 2D axisymmetric Finite Element simulations. Material parameters are experimentally determined. Contact and transformation plasticity effects among others are implemented in Abaqus® with user subroutines. The study aims to optimize the mandrel diameter of a fixture hardening tool for processing of planet gears. Plasticity, transformation plasticity, arising contact forces, and pressure depending on different mandrel sizes are investigated in depth. Distortion is evaluated and an optimal setting is derived from the calculations. Results show that cylindricity, defined here as the difference between maximum and minimum radius of the part, and maximum contact pressure, both can be reduced by increasing the mandrel radius. Physical effects and distortion evolve strongly nonlinear. Analysis methods highlighting cylindricity depending on the different mandrel diameters are developed to illustrate this nonlinear behavior and to enhance knowledge about the process.