The Influences of Sex, Gender Identity, and Power on Faculty-Graduate Student Relational Mentoring and its Association with Student Psychological Health

Abstract

Evidence suggests that university student psychological health problems may be increasing, and graduate students may be at increased risk for problems such as depression relative to the general population. The limited extant research has identified a correlation between relational mentoring characterized by mutual authenticity, engagement, and empowerment, and female undergraduate student psychological health.The current research fills gaps in the mentoring and feminist psychological literatures by examining this correlation in faculty-graduate student mentoring and testing key assumptions of relational-cultural theory, from which the concept of relational mentoring is derived. Relational-cultural theory assumes: 1) relational mentoring is more important to the psychological health of women than men, and 2) women are more likely than men to adopt a relationship style that would foster relational mentoring. This research was also informed by feminist critiques of these assumptions. Consequently, using a survey of 421 graduate students from various disciplines across Canada, Study 1 examined the association between faculty-graduate student relational mentoring and psychological health outcomes. Study 1 further tested the moderating effects of student sex, gender identity (i.e., masculine, feminine traits), and the power dynamics of the individual faculty-student relationships. A significant correlation was observed between relational mentoring and positive psychological health (i.e., decreased depressive symptoms, increased self-esteem and life satisfaction). This association was not moderated by student sex, gender identity, or relationship power dynamics. Using an online, experimental design and a sample of 186 undergraduate students, Study 2 examined the effects of sex, gender identity, and a randomly assigned power condition (i.e., high-power RELATIONAL MENTORING AND PSYCHOLOGICAL HEALTH iii faculty mentor versus low-power student) on relationship styles in mentoring. Sex and gender identity influenced mentoring relationship styles (i.e., female participants and those with more feminine traits were associated with greater authenticity, engagement, and empowerment), and a notable interaction emerged. Specifically, sex differences in relationship style were observed in the high-power faculty mentor condition (i.e., female mentors were more authentic, engaged, empowering) but not the low-power student condition. Collectively, the results provide mixed support for relational-cultural theory.The results may be used to guide faculty-graduate student mentoring practices (e.g., student selection of mentors) to enhance graduate student psychological health. RELATIONAL MENTORING AND PSYCHOLOGICAL HEALTH iv Acknowledgements This thesis could not have been completed without the help and support of several individuals and organizations. First, I must thank my thesis advisor and mentor, Dr. Shelley Brown, for her support in this process. I appreciate the insight and guidance provided by members of my committee, Dr. Fran Cher...

<p>Prevalence and associated factors of depression and anxiety among doctoral students: the mediating effect of mentoring relationships on the association between research self-efficacy and depression/anxiety</p>

“…Peluso et al found that the academic advisor relationship played a role in protecting the mental health of experimental psychology students in Canada 10. Gottschall also showed a significant association between a harmonious mentoring relationship (RHI-M subscale) and decreased depressive symptoms among Canadian graduate students 66. In addition, Lunsford suggested that mentoring by doctoral advisors correlated with student outcomes, including satisfaction and academic production 37…”

Athletic Training Students' Perceptions of Mentorship in Clinical Education

“…In unpublished data, 27 it is suggested that women display more feminine traits (authentic, engaged, etc), and thus, these traits can better guide the development of the mentoring relationship. Our sample population was predominately female; thus, this could provide some context to our findings; that is, female athletic training students want their mentors and preceptors to exhibit what is commonly referred to as sexspecific traits.…”

Radical Empathy in Teaching

“…). In the graduate context, Gottshall () found significant correlation between mentoring and positive psychological health, as indicated by decreased depressive symptoms, increased self‐esteem, and life satisfaction while McMillan‐Roberts () established that faculty mentors helped doctoral students develop a scholar‐practitioner identity. Looking specifically at meaningful academic relationships between master's students and professors, Schwartz and Holloway () found evidence of The Five Good Things (Miller ), as both students and professors reported increased energy, boosts in sense of worth, increased understanding, the ability to keep moving in their work, and a desire for more connection.…”