“…However, ENSO forecast remains challenging (Barnston et al, 2012;Chen & Cane, 2008;Kirtman & Schopf, 1998;Latif et al, 1998;. Actually, from the perspective of error growth dynamics, it has been investigated that the SPB for ENSO is the result of the combined effect of the climatological annual cycle, the ENSO itself, and the particular pattern of initial errors (Duan & Hu, 2015;Duan & Wei, 2012;Mu, Duan, & Wang, 2007;Ren et al, 2016). The spring persistence barrier has been shown to physically correlate with the sudden reduction of ENSO forecast skills across spring in various climate models, that is, the spring predictability barrier (SPB; McPhaden, 2003;Mu, Xu, & Duan, 2007;Masuda et al, 2015).…”