The interrupted learner: How distractions during live and video lectures influence learning outcomes

Abstract

New instructional technologies have been increasingly incorporated into the medical school learning environment, including lecture video recordings as a substitute for live lecture attendance. The literature presents varying conclusions regarding how this alternative experience impacts students' academic success. Previously, a multi-year study of the first-year medical histology component at the University of Michigan found that live lecture attendance was positively correlated with learning success, while lecture video use was negatively correlated. Here, three cohorts of first-year medical students (N = 439 respondents, 86.6% response rate) were surveyed in greater detail regarding lecture attendance and video usage, focusing on study behaviors that may influence histology learning outcomes. Students who reported always attending lectures or viewing lecture videos had higher average histology scores than students who employed an inconsistent strategy (i.e., mixing live attendance and video lectures). Several behaviors were negatively associated with histology performance. Students who engaged in "non-lecture activities" (e.g., social media use), students who reported being interrupted while watching the lecture video, or feeling sleepy/losing focus had lower scores than their counterparts not engaging in these behaviors. This study suggests that interruptions and distractions during medical learning activities-whether live or recorded-can have an important impact on learning outcomes. Anat Sci Educ 11: 366-376. © 2017 American Association of Anatomists.

Perceptions of medical students towards online teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic: a national cross-sectional survey of 2721 UK medical students

“… 57 Also, watching pre-recorded lectures, alongside the possibility of attending face-to-face lecture, has been shown to negatively correlate with learning success. 58 …”

Breaking with Tradition: A Scoping Meta‐Analysis Analyzing the Effects of Student‐Centered Learning and Computer‐Aided Instruction on Student Performance in Anatomy

“…One theory is that the overall effectiveness of lectures has been derailed by distractive and/or disruptive technologies. Some studies indicate that non‐academic laptop use in classrooms is negatively correlated with student exam performance (Ravizza et al, ; Zureick et al, ). Alternatively, student‐centered approaches and CAI are often intentionally designed to embrace and capitalize on the use of technology, thereby lessening the effects of its disruptiveness.…”

Inoculating a New Generation: Immunology in Medical Education

“…Viewing a video of a good lecture cannot adequately replace the dynamic of attending a good lecture, with the opportunity to view the spectrum of instructor-student interactions, questions, and comments. Video recording of lectures also inevitably leads to a decrease in attendance, resulting in less interaction with instructors and with peers (27).…”