The involvement of service users in the assessment of Diploma in Social Work students on practice placements

Abstract

The government, local authorities and academic institutions in the United Kingdom all positively support the involvement of service users in social work practice and education. Based upon research undertaken for a Master's dissertation, this article argues for such an inclusive approach. The author works for the Training and Development Services of an English Social and Caring Services department, which delivers a Diploma in Social Work course in collaboration with the local university college. This course began to incorporate service users' views in the assessment of students on practice placements in the mid-1990s. This was a helpful development, although areas of ambiguity and difficulty became apparent, as did a lack of clarity and consistency in the implementation of the process. A qualitative survey of the views of practice teachers was conducted by meansof semi-structured interviews, which focussed on the main principles, issues and practical implications of service user involvement in the assessment of DipSW students. The article offers a summary of the findings of the survey, and a critical discussion of the main issues and difficulties that emerged. Some recommendations are made for the course that the author is associated with, although they would probably apply to most DipSW courses in the United Kingdom. The author is male, white and British.

Mental health consumer participation in undergraduate occupational therapy student assessment: No negative impact

“…Although consumer participation is recommended in all professions and mandated in some, students and health practitioner educators have expressed concerns about consumers' capacity to contribute effectively to the teaching and learning in undergraduate courses (Babu et al, 2008;Edwards, 2003;Ikkos, 2003;Morgan & Jones, 2009;O'Donnell & Gormley, 2013). This is especially true in relation to their involvement in the assessment of students.…”

'My Expectations Remain the Same. The Student Has to Be Competent to Practise': Practice Assessor Perspectives on the New Social Work Degree Qualification in England

“…Research (Edwards, 2003;Levin, 2004) has shown that service user and carer involvement in assessing practice learning has been uneven. Although there were signs of a clear trend towards greater involvement, it appeared that the process has been incremental and continues to be more informal than systematic.…”

“…Service users and carers had been involved in assessing practice learning under the DipSW but not consistently (Edwards, 2003) so the requirement for service user and carer involvement in all aspects of the degree (Department of Health, 2002b, p. 9) was an important change.…”

Sowing the seeds of change: trainee clinical psychologists' experiences of service user and carer involvement on placement

“…Edwards (2003) does consider this issue in relation to the training of social work students but placements often constitute a significant aspect of mental health training for a much wider range of professionals. An understanding of service user and carer involvement on placements could offer crucial information to develop thinking about how meaningful involvement can be achieved and the impact that this might have on the mental health professionals of the future.…”