The issue of gauge choice in the Landau problem and the physics of canonical and mechanical orbital angular momenta

Abstract

One intriguing issue in the nucleon spin decomposition problem is the existence of two types of decompositions, which are representably characterized by two different orbital angular momenta (OAMs) of quarks. The one is the mechanical OAM, while the other is the so-called gauge-invariant canonical (g.i.c.) OAM, the concept of which was introduced by Chen et al. An especially delicate quantity is the g.i.c. OAM, which must be distinguished from the ordinary (gauge-variant) canonical OAM. We find that, owing to its analytically solvable nature, the famous Landau problem offers an ideal tool to understand the difference and the physical meaning of the above three OAMs, i.e. the standard canonical OAM, g.i.c. OAM, and the mechanical OAM. We analyze these three OAMs in two different formulations of the Landau problem, first in the standard (gauge-fixed) formulation and second in the gauge-invariant (but path-dependent) formulation of DeWitt. Especially interesting is the latter formalism. It is shown that the choice of path has an intimate connection with the choice of gauge, but they are not necessarily equivalent. Then, we answer the question about what is the consequence of a particular choice of path in DeWitt's formalism. This analysis also clarifies the implication of the gauge symmetry hidden in the concept of g.i.c. OAM. Finally, we show that the finding above offers a clear understanding about the uniqueness or non-uniqueness problem of the nucleon spin decomposition, which arises from the arbitrariness in the definition of the so-called physical component of the gauge field.

Weak decays of magnetized charged pions in the symmetric gauge

“…As noticed in Ref. [21], the consequences of the axial symmetry of the problem, as well as the physical meaning of angular momenta, can be better understood if one works in the symmetric gauge. Having this in mind, the purpose of the present work is to rederive the expression for the π − → lν l decay width in the presence of a uniform magnetic field, now considering the symmetric gauge.…”

The physics of helical electron beam in a uniform magnetic field as a testing ground of gauge principle

“…We recall that spatial integrals of these quantities, which are just the expectation values of the corresponding operator in the Landau state ψ n,m , are well-known. They are given by [13], [14] l can…”

The role of electron orbital angular momentum in the Aharonov–Bohm effect revisited

“…Is there still any reason that favors one particular path choice ? As shown in our previous study of the Landau problem [15], the symmetry plays an important role in selecting a physically favorable path in DeWitt's formulation of electrodynamics. An advantage of the path choice C I is that it respects the axial symmetry of the gauge potential with respect to the z-axis.…”

“…In particular, can we find a path which reproduces the potential in the generalized 2nd Landau gauge discussed before ? The answer is simple, when the point (x, y) lies inside the solenoid of radius R. In this case, we can use the knowledge already known from our previous study of the Landau problem [15], and the answer is given byÃ…”