While engaged in research on the long-necked lute called Herati dutdr in 1974,1 was frequently told about a virtuoso dutdri (dutdr player) who had died a few years earlier after a fight with a gang of 'thugs' in the city of Kandahar. His name was Amin-e Diwaneh. The Persian word diwaneh means 'crazy', and was applied to people who (in terms of Western psychiatry) might be classed as 'insane', though the cause of insanity was usually attributed to spirit possession. Diwaneh was also a description for individuals who were particularly erratic in their behaviour, and was often used affectionately. Amin the dutdri was such a person.Amin-e Diwaneh was said to have been a remarkable dutdr player; in his hands the dutdr 'talked', or 'shouted', it sang like a crazy spirit. He was said to have a special gift from God (bakshish-e Khoddi). He was described as the best dutdr player in Afghanistan; no other dutdri could 'play in front of him'. Although he was a selftaught musician it was claimed that he played better than the hereditary professional musicians (sdzandeh), who received musical training from an early age. He was very eccentric, certainly in terms of Afghan norms of behaviour. He wore his shirt front undone, exposing his chest, a degree of public nakedness which was considered quite unusual, and he wore metal amulets (tawiz) around his neck. He always carried his dutdr around with him, whereas other musicians concealed their instruments in public, for they were often criticised by orthodox Muslims for engaging in 'the work of Satan'. Amin would play anywhere, in teahouses, even in the bazaar.He was said to be 'deep' in his life; although he moved in this world he seemed to be in another. Many people were frightened by him and his reputation for being a diwaneh, a madman, but he appealed to the 'Majnun types', those who rejected the norms and conventions of society at large, and who, like Majnun (in the famous tale of Leyli and Majnun) wanted to get away, to be alone in the desert. Such people, described as having complexes about life, sadnesses, dissatisfactions -who rejected the world of material things -they liked him and called him Diwaneh out of respect and admiration. And he liked such people and responded to them. He was a charsi, a habitual smoker of hashish (or chars as cannabis resin is called in Afghanistan) and he could be very aggressive. Towards the end of his life he gave up living in the city and became an itinerant amongst the ziydrats, the shrines of Sufi saints which abound in the Herat valley. He was then likened to a malang, a type of religious mendicant who inhabited such places. These were the kinds of comments made about Amin-e Diwaneh by other dutdr players.Herat, where Amin lived and died, is the third largest city in Afghanistan, and is located in the west, 80 miles from the border with Iran, and far from Kabul, Afghanistan's capital, situated in the east. Herat was a provincial city, which since the 1930s had in musical terms been orientated towards Kabul, although Herat's