The limits of representation activism: analyzing Black celebrity politics in LeBron James’ The Shop

Abstract

This discussion centers on a critical textual analysis of 10 episodes of The Shop: Uninterrupted, an HBO television series produced by and starring iconic Black American basketball player LeBron James. The aim is to provide a considered explication of representation activism: the anti-racist strategy keying on collapsing racial hierarchies through accenting positive Black representation, and so advancing greater Black inclusion, within mainstream media (Andrews, 2018; Gilroy, 2000; Godsil and Goodale, 2013). The politics and constructions of Blackness within The Shop exemplify the logical flaws, superficiality, and insipid practical outcomes of representation activism. Though The Shop proclaims to demonstrate Black liberatory representation, this analysis elucidates how The Shop’s centering of the Black celebrity elite as the agents of change falsely universalizes the experiences of everyday Black people; its pursuit of a mythological Black authenticity essentializes and romanticizes Black vernacular and identities; and its mediation through the White racial frame prohibits the articulation of an effective liberatory politics. The discussion concludes by challenging the possibilities of “positive” representation in capitalist media as a credible and sincere tactic of collective Black liberation (Hooks, 1992; Marable, 2015; Spence, 2015; West, 1994); instead, suggesting a grassroots-oriented approach prefigured on targeting the structural roots of racism.

“Willpower knows no obstacles”: Examining Neoliberal Postfeminist Messaging in Nike’s Transnational Advertisements for Women

“…We note that our interpretations reflect one particular reading of Nike’s advertisements, a reading shaped by our positions as academics in US-based universities and experiences with Nike marketing campaigns. Following Markula and Silk (2011), we understand textual analysis as an analytic method that interprets the content and meaning of “texts” (which can include written or visual communications) as articulated within and structured in relation to cultural or ideological power relations (Wallace & Andrews, 2021). While viewing the advertisements multiple times, we systematically coded their contents, keeping a separate codebook for each advertisement.…”

Trans*Mediation: Exploring Trans Experience Beyond the Mirror of Representation

“…This connection between "good" media and social injustice is evidently not so direct, however, and the troubling of its narrative is by no means new. Numerous marginalized groups have also worked to address a history of harmful and stereotypical media through improved representation and have encountered similar issues, including the representation of Blackness (Wallace & Andrews, 2021), femininity (Bray & Colebrook, 1998), queerness (Tongson, 2017), and disability (Fox et al, 2018;Samuels, 2003). Like trans media representation, the representation of these groups in media is argued to be important for the broader cultural understanding of the group but has been critiqued for continuing to amplify otherwise privileged voices and erasing any identities who differ.…”