The Long Arm of Oppression: How Structural Stigma Against Marginalized Communities Perpetuates Within-Group Health Disparities

Abstract

Understanding and addressing health inequities calls for enhanced theoretical and empirical attention to multiple forms of stigma and its influence on health behaviors and health outcomes within marginalized communities. While recent scholarship highlights the role of structural stigma on between-group health disparities, the extant literature has yet to elucidate the mechanisms through which structural stigma gives rise to within-group health disparities. In this article, we review and use relevant literature to inform the development of a conceptual model outlining how structural stigma contributes to within-group health disparities by creating division and tension within communities marginalized due to their social statuses and identities. We specifically focus on disparities among (1) communities of color due to White supremacy, (2) gender and sexual minority communities due to patriarchy and heterosexism, and (3) the disability community due to ableism. We argue that the nature and extent of the stigma members of stigmatized communities face are intricately tied to how visible the stigmatized characteristic is to others. By visibility, we refer to characteristics that are more easily perceived by others, and reveal a person’s social identity (e.g., race/ethnicity, nativity, relationship status, gender expression, and disability status). This paper advances the literature by discussing the implications of the model for future research, practice, and policy, including the importance of acknowledging the ways in which structural stigma intentionally disrupts the collective identity and solidarity of communities and consequently threatens health equity.

Assistance dogs for military veterans with PTSD: A systematic review, meta-analysis, and meta-synthesis

“…The loss of social participation due to isolation, common among veterans with PTSD, is clearly profoundly detrimental: both to the individual’s own well-being as well as to the community which is unable to benefit from their unique perspective and potential contributions. Moreover, as members of the community of people with invisible disabilities (i.e., disabilities that cannot be easily identified visually), veterans with PTSD may experience distress not only as a direct result of their symptoms, but also due to stigma and invalidation from the community–including from within the disabled community itself [ 98 ]. Researchers must take into account the fact that for these veterans, partnership with a psychiatric assistance dog is effectively a disclosure of disability (and possibly also veteran) status, and can therefore lead to increased discrimination.…”

Women’s Empowerment, Research, and Management: Their Contribution to Social Sustainability

“…Structural stigma rooted in patriarchy is tied to social identities based on gender and has historically and contemporaneously marginalized women from society, with an impact in its sustainability and equilibrium. This ideology permeates everyday life through the institutions, policies, and systems that perpetuate it, and can either be assumed or rejected by the communities subjected to exclusion [51,52]. Gender-based structural stigma leads to social hierarchies based on differences in terms of sex, which are reflected in culturally ascribed stereotypes.…”

Gender Identity, Disability, and Unmet Healthcare Needs among Disabled People Living in the Community in the United States

“…Additionally, people with disabilities face discriminatory employment environments [ 14 ], impoverishment [ 15 ], higher rates of arrests and incarceration [ 16 , 17 ], and stigma [ 18 , 19 ], as well as barriers to healthcare [ 7 , 20 ]. Some barriers include the prohibitive costs of care [ 21 ], a lack of health-adequate insurance coverage, a lack of transportation [ 22 ], personal and cultural barriers [ 22 ], and a lack of knowledge among medical professionals about disability [ 22 , 23 ].…”

“…As a result, for example, disabled people of color may experience compounding adversities due to systemic inequities [ 5 , 32 ]. While disabled people have a higher probability of arrest compared to people without disabilities, Black disabled people have an even higher probability of arrest compared to whites with disabilities [ 17 ]. Black and Indigenous people living with disabilities have the highest poverty rates compared to all other people, with or without a disability [ 33 ].…”