“…Previously 5 we reported a factor 9 heavyatom 1°kinetic isotope effect (KIE) in the loss of a chlorine atom from CH 2 35 Cl 37 Cl + , a very low KER, and a massive H/D 2°KIE. In a recent publication, 6 applying a revised main beam correction term, we reported the KER for the loss of Cl from CH 2 35 Cl 2 + to be 30 μeV or borderline zero, presumably the lowest KER ever reported from a MIKE experiment. Other sources report KERs of 10−15 meV, 17−19 but these values are most likely incorrect due to an unrecognized contribution from CID. In our first report, 5 we also concluded that no metastable reaction was detectable for CD 2 Cl 2 + .…”