“…Our study shows that this preference hinges critically on the timing of complex call production: females prefer males that produce a complex call. All males are capable of producing complex calls but choose to do so depending on the social environment, with complex calls more commonly produced (1) during bouts of vocal competition between neighbouring males (Bernal et al 2009), (2) in the presence of females (K. L. Akre, personal communication), (3) when predation risk is perceived to be lower (Tuttle et al 1982;Jennions & Backwell 1992;Phelps et al 2007) and (4) when injected with arginine vasotocin (Kime et al 2007), a neuropeptide that modulates social behaviour in many species (Moore & Miller 1983;Boyd 1994;Chu et al 1998;Marler et al 1999;Sanantgelo & Bass 2006). We show that the continued production of complex calls is critical when females are assessing and approaching potential mates, and therefore, males should be under selection to maintain complexity during peak female attendance at the chorus or when females are detected directly.…”