Arrestin-1 (visual arrestin) binds to light-activated phosphorylated rhodopsin (P-Rh*) to terminate G-protein signaling. To map conformational changes upon binding to the receptor, pairs of spin labels were introduced in arrestin-1 and double electron-electron resonance was used to monitor interspin distance changes upon P-Rh* binding. The results indicate that the relative position of the N and C domains remains largely unchanged, contrary to expectations of a "clam-shell" model. A loop implicated in P-Rh* binding that connects β-strands V and VI (the "finger loop," residues 67-79) moves toward the expected location of P-Rh* in the complex, but does not assume a fully extended conformation. A striking and unexpected movement of a loop containing residue 139 away from the adjacent finger loop is observed, which appears to facilitate P-Rh* binding. This change is accompanied by smaller movements of distal loops containing residues 157 and 344 at the tips of the N and C domains, which correspond to "plastic" regions of arrestin-1 that have distinct conformations in monomers of the crystal tetramer. Remarkably, the loops containing residues 139, 157, and 344 appear to have high flexibility in both free arrestin-1 and the P-Rh*complex.A rrestin was first discovered in the visual system as a protein that blocks ("arrests") the signaling of the prototypical G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) rhodopsin (Rh) via specific binding to the phosphorylated activated form P-Rh* (1). Mammals express four arrestin subtypes: Arrestin-1 and -4 are specific for the visual system, whereas arrestin-2 and -3 are ubiquitous (2). [We use systematic names of arrestins: arrestin-1 (historic names S-antigen, 48-kDa protein, or visual or rod arrestin), arrestin-2 (β-arrestin or β-arrestin1), arrestin-3 (β-arrestin2 or hTHY-ARRX), and arrestin-4 (cone or X-arrestin).] The discovery of nonvisual arrestins (3) showed that phosphorylation followed by arrestin binding is a common mechanism of GPCR regulation. Crystal structures of all four arrestin subtypes in their basal state revealed similar topology: two cup-like domains linked by an interdomain hinge ( Fig. 1) (4-7). Arrestin-1 was proposed to undergo a conformational rearrangement during the P-Rh* interaction that results in the release of the C-terminal sequence (C tail) (8, 9) but does not involve major secondary structure changes (8, 10). Recent site-directed spin labeling (SDSL) studies identified specific parts of arrestin-1 engaged by different functional forms of rhodopsin and provided direct evidence of binding-induced conformational changes (11,12). A conformational change in the so-called finger loop (Fig. 1) implicated in P-Rh* recognition was also observed using NMR and fluorescence quenching (13,14). Arrestin-1 shows a remarkable selectivity for P-Rh*. Observed binding to inactive phosphorylated (P-Rh) or active unphosphorylated rhodopsin (Rh*) is usually less than 10% of the binding to P-Rh*, whereas its binding to inactive unphosphorylated rhodopsin (Rh) is barely detectable ...