The mundane realities of the everyday lay use of the internet for health, and their consequences for media convergence

Abstract

The internet is now a major source of health information for lay people. Within the medical, sociological and popular literatures there have been three main responses to this development. We classify these as 'celebratory', 'concerned' and 'contingent'. This paper falls into the third category and, drawing on techniques of discourse analysis, examines people's accounts of their use of online health resources. It identifies six implicit rules -which we call 'rhetorics of reliability' -that people readily draw upon when articulating why they trust some online sources and not others. In addition participants locate their accounts within broader discursive frameworks in order to present themselves as 'sensible' users. The article concludes by suggesting that there is an emerging concordance between the lay use of the internet for health and illness and dominant (generally) biomedical conceptions of what constitutes 'good quality' health information.

Characterizing the Digital Health Citizen: Mixed-Methods Study Deriving a New Typology (Preprint)

“…This confirms that previously existing health behaviours translate to the online realm [28,31,32], as well as an emphasis on attitudes and skills as mediators for internet outcomes [17]. In that sense, online health resources become part of normal health practices, help-seeking, and everyday life information-seeking [33][34][35]. This ties in with the wider argument that individuals use technologies to satisfy existing needs, with technological innovation merely creating new ways of doing so [36], as reflected in theories around the social shaping of technology [37].…”

An Exploratory Study on the Consumers Use of Medicine in the State of Sarawak, Malaysia

“…Experiential knowledge and applicability were likely to be considered by ethnic minorities. 16 Pharmacists must be aware of side effects or even adverse drug reactions (ADRs) that were common in their community that served in, do the necessary reporting to Malaysian Adverse Drug Reactions Advisory Committee (MADRAC) for pharmacovigilance purposes and research in these fields in that community, as most 'theoretical' side effects in the literature are that of Caucasians or major Asian groups only. However, more respondents from urban area (31.2%) choose to consult private doctors compared to those from rural area (13.0%).…”

The many faces of diabetes: A critical multimodal analysis of diabetes pages on Facebook

“…Early sociological work on 'e-health' was frequently optimistic about the potential of the web to empower lay users by offering them ready access to medical information with which they could reflexively understand their conditions and make informed health choices (Nettleton and Burrows, 2003). Celebratory accounts also claimed that the Internet would disrupt the paternalistic, professionalised hierarchies of traditional healthcare through the growth of lay expertise (Nettleton et al, 2005). Hardey (1999Hardey ( , 2001, for instance, argued that public participation on the web would mean that medical discourses would no longer be the preserve of medical professionals and that alternative representations of health and illness based on patient experience would be able to emerge.…”