DNA polymerase (pol) b catalyzes two reactions at DNA gaps generated during base excision repair; gap-filling DNA synthesis and lyase-dependent 5' end deoxyribose phosphate removal. The lyase domain of pol β has been proposed to function in DNA gap recognition and to facilitate DNA scanning during substrate search. However, the mechanisms and molecular interactions used by pol b for substrate search and recognition are not clear. To provide insight into this process, a comparison was made of the DNA binding affinities of wild-type pol b, pol l and pol μ, and several variants of pol b, for 1-nt gap containing and undamaged DNA. Surprisingly, this analysis revealed that mutation of three lysine residues in the lyase active site of pol b, 35, 68 and 72, to alanine (pol b K∆3A), increased the binding affinity for non-specific DNA ~11-fold as compared to wild-type. Wild-type pol μ, lacking homologous lysines, displayed similar non-specific DNA binding behavior as pol b K∆3A, in line with previous data demonstrating both enzymes were deficient in processive searching. In fluorescent microscopy experiments using mouse fibroblasts deficient in PARP-1, the ability of pol b K∆3A to localize to sites of laser-induced DNA damage was strongly decreased, as compared to wild-type pol b. These data suggest that the three lysines in the lyase active site destabilize pol b when bound to DNA non-specifically, promoting DNA scanning and providing binding specificity for gapped DNA.