The nature of the Tunguska meteorite

Abstract

Abstract-Arguments in favor of the cometary origin of the Tunguska meteorite are adduced along with reasons against the asteroidal hypothesis. A critical analysis is given for the hypotheses by Sekanina (1983) and Chyba et al. (1 993). On the basis of the azimuth and inclination of the trajectory of the Tunguska body with plausible values of the geocentric velocity, the semimajor axis of the orbit and its inclination to the ecliptic plane are calculated for this body. It is noted that the theory of the disintegration of large bodies in the atmosphere put forward by Chyba et al. (1993) is crude. Applying more accurate theories (Grigoryan, 1979;Hills and Goda, 1993) as well as taking into account the realistic shape of the body yield for the cometary body lower disruption heights than obtained by Chyba et al. Numerical simulations carried out by Svettsov et al. agree well with the cometary hypothesis and the analytical calculations based on Grigoryan's theory. The asteroidal hypothesis is shown not to be tenable: the complete lack of stony fragments in the region of the catastrophe, cosmochemical data (in particular, the results of an isotope analysis), and some other information contradict this hypothesis. It is shown that stony fragments that would have originated in the explosive disruption of the Tunguska body would not be vaporized by the radiation of the vapor cloud nor as a result of their fall to the Earth's surface.

Survivability of Bacteria in Hypervelocity Impact

“…However, a planet such as the Earth possesses an atmosphere which can help decelerate small bodies. The results are the well-known influx of dust into the Earth's atmosphere (Love and Brownlee 1993), the collection of small meteorites on the Earth's surface, and the explosion of some larger bodies in the atmosphere due to the shock they undergo during descent (e.g., Tunguska) (Bronshten 1999). Although destructive of the parent body, the latter process can shower the region below with small components of the initial body.…”

Anthropogenic- and natural sources of dust in peatland during the Anthropocene

“…2) and is the best known and most mysterious extra-terrestrial event recorded in Central Russia; the amount of cosmic material dispersed into the atmosphere has been estimated at ca 1 million tons3839.…”

An adaptive moving mesh method with application to non-stationary hypersonic flows in the atmosphere

“…In this analysis the hypothesis of the meteorite nature of the Tunguska object is followed [24]. Although a detailed discussion on this question is beyond the scope of the current paper, it is to be noted that the meteorite hypothesis is earnestly supported by the observation data [23]. Indeed, in spite of vast efforts of many expeditions to the area of the impact, there have not been found any solid debris of the Tunguska object.…”