The new cultural norm: reasons why UK foundation doctors are choosing not to go straight into speciality training

Abstract

Background: The number of UK foundation doctors choosing to go straight into speciality training has fallen drastically over the last 10 years: We sought to explore and understand the reasons for this change. Methods: We undertook semi-structured interviews with 16 foundation year two doctors, who had not applied to speciality training, from two regional foundation schools. Transcripts were thematically analysed. Results: The reasons that foundation doctors are choosing not to go straight into speciality training centre around the themes of feeling undervalued, career uncertainty and a new cultural norm. They report major feelings of uncertainty regarding career choice at such an early stage of their profession and this challenge was magnified by a perceived lack of flexibility of training and the growing normality of taking time out from training. Trainees feel a lack of support in planning and undertaking an "FY3" year and being helped back into the workforce. Trainees overwhelmingly reported that they feel undervalued by their employers. Importantly, however, not going into training directly was not always a reflection of dissatisfaction with training. Many trainees spoke very positively about their planned activities and often saw a break in training as an excellent way to recharge, develop skills and prepare for the rest of their careers in medicine. Conclusions: Taking a year or more out of training after foundation years has become the new cultural norm for UK junior doctors and reasons for this include feeling undervalued, career uncertainty and the perception that this is now "normal". Exploring these factors with participants has generated a number of recommendations related to improving the workplace environment, allowing more flexibility in training and supporting those who chose to take an FY3.

Exploring Doctors’ Emerging Commitment to Rural and General Practice Roles over Their Early Career

“…These junior doctors are often encouraged to experience many different specialty roles and departments during these early postgraduate years, which perhaps reassures delaying the need to lock in specialty decisions. Junior doctors in the UK note that "you don't want to get that [decision] wrong" [25].…”

How do medical schools influence their students’ career choices? A realist evaluation

“…Although all participants had stated career choice at recruitment, at interview two participants revealed they did not have firm career preferences and three were considering delaying entry to speciality training. This trend to take a training break at the end of foundation training rather than continuing with specialty training immediately is recognised [ 38 , 39 ] and is designated ‘F3’ in Table 1 .…”

Understanding the non‐professional needs of early career doctors: An interview‐based study

“…The demand for flexibility in training programs has been acknowledged in past studies, particularly in the context of allowing doctors more freedom to individualise their training needs, including training locations 24,48–50 . Expectations of the likely requirement for doctors to be flexible in their training location were not, however, directly explored in our interviews.…”