The Options by Context Approach: A Paradigm Shift in Agronomy

Abstract

SUMMARYInnovation in agronomy by large numbers of smallholder farmers will need to accelerate if global commitments to end hunger are to be achieved in the face of major climate and other global change that are both caused by, and impact, agriculture. Conventional research and development in agronomy have involved a research process that produces technologies, which are then promoted for uptake by large numbers of farmers through extension, with both research and extension phases being more or less participatory. Recent research, including key contributions to this special issue, reveals that the performance of many technology options varies hugely across the geographies over which development programmes operate, depending on social, economic and ecological context. This severely limits the value of attempting to produce recommendations for large areas and numbers of farmers and identifies the need for new ways of supporting innovation that address the real-world heterogeneity of farmer circumstances. Addressing this widespread phenomenon of option by context interaction (OxC) has profound implications for how agronomic research and development are organised. Papers in this special issue show the nature and implications of such interactions and suggest ways in which research and development systems need to respond in order to support locally relevant innovation. It is evident that a paradigm shift is well underway, with researchers embracing new modes of thinking and action required to address OxC interactions, but these also need to be taken up and further developed by extension and change agents in the public and private sector. It is only through continued co-development of methods involving both these constituencies, working closely with farmers that sufficient progress is likely to be made for smallholder farming to keep pace with global demand for food without further damaging the environmental resources upon which production is based.

National extension policy and state-level implementation: The case of Cross River State, Nigeria

“…Furthermore, the goals and purposes of agriculture and food systems policy have developed from a principal focus on production to wider coverage of the mechanisms of value chains and the dynamics of market-oriented poverty reduction goals (Davidson and Ahmad 2002;Abdu-Raheem and Worth 2016). The reforms were also a response to a marked change in the profile of agricultural firms, farms, and the target population of extension and advisory services in many countries (Quaye et al 2019;Sinclair and Coe 2019). Against this backdrop, we included the private sector in the dialogue and consultative process.…”

User-centred design of a digital advisory service: enhancing public agricultural extension for sustainable intensification in Tanzania

“…The first challenge is that farmers must be enabled to identify the right solutions for specific contexts (Godfray, 2015;Petersen & Snapp, 2015). The heterogeneity of farming systems, market opportunities, and agro-climate may require a diversity of changes at different spatial scales, as no single SI practice is viable everywhere (Sinclair & Coe, 2019); The second challenge is that many SI practices require farmers to acquire complex knowledge.…”

A Planetary Health Perspective on Agroforestry in Sub-Saharan Africa

“…Baseline-to-future comparisons for other important agroforestry tree species in Sub-Saharan Africa indicate a similar pattern, with overall more ''climate losers'' than ''climate winners,'' as has also been predicted for Meso-America. 155 While agroforestry may help us adapt cropping and livestock systems to climate change and reduce atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide, existing evidence reinforces the imperative to match the right tree to the right location, 156 considering not only current but also likely future climate scenarios. Institutions Institutions-when broadly considered as social rules and norms that govern behavior-contribute to the challenges to adoption of agroforestry technologies.…”