The Paradiplomatic Role of the ConIFA in Promoting Self-Determination of Marginalised Entities

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to apply the paradiplomacy framework in exploring the role of NGOs in promoting the issue of marginalised peoples. More specifically, it highlights the Confederation of Independent Football Association (ConIFA), an international football governing body comprising minority peoples, stateless nations, and regions which are unrecognised by the Federation Internationale de Football Association (FIFA). The author attempts to discuss ConIFA’s ability in voicing the issue of self-determination concerning its members, which are mainly sidelined in the mainstream international affairs. This paper discusses two questions: (1) does ConIFA qualify to be regarded as a paradiplomatic actor? If yes, in what ways? and (2) to what extent does ConIFA advocate the issue of self-determination of its members? In so doing, the researcher first studies the nature of ConIFA through its own constitution as well as examining its activities through various sources. Second, the author also utilises core concepts on paradiplomacy to seek in which category does ConIFA’s activities fall into. The findings suggest that ConIFA qualifies as a paradiplomatic actor in the sense that it has two forces: horizontal and vertical. Horizontally, it platforms its members to interact with like-minded counterparts through numerous activities. Vertically, ConIFA also possesses a comparative advantage to reach a wider audience by framing the issue through sport. However, the study also indicates that while self-determination is promoted through ConIFA, the organisation does not possess enough political capacity to facilitate a deeper advocacy, thus making its paradiplomatic activities mainly fall into the cultural category.

Aktor dan ‘Actorness’ Dalam Amalan Paradiplomasi Global: Suatu Sorotan Literatur

“…Peranan Badan Bukan Kerajaan (NGO) sebagai salah satu aktor paradiplomasi yang signifikan disentuh oleh Utomo (2019). Beliau merujuk kepada Confederation of Independent Football Association (ConIFA) sebagai medium representasi bagi aktor-aktor minoriti seperti warga tiada negara de facto (stateless group), golongan ditindas dan sebahagian wakil negara yang tidak diiktiraf Pertubuhan Bolesepak Antarabangsa (FIFA).…”

Small Islands in International Relations: Bermuda’s Sports Paradiplomacy

“…For semi-autonomous regions, especially those still struggling with projecting their unique identity, sport provides a relatively safe pathway to display themselves as a region with a distinctive identity. Sport is a low-politics issue that allows these regions to stay respectful toward their parent state's sovereignty but, on the other hand, also allows them to project their own uniqueness without causing any signi cant backlash (Utomo, 2019). Also, engaging in international sporting competitions allows lesser political units to compete with other sovereign nations and therefore projects their identity as a distinctive political unit in the international forum.…”

Paradiplomacy of Indonesian Sub-State Actor: Digital Diplomacy of Jakarta Government in Response to Covid-19

“…Paradiplomacy between American and Chinese cities was studied by Leffel and Amiri (2018). Paradiplomacy is the arena not only for sub-national governments, but also for non-governmental organizations as studied by Utomo (2019). The study showed that ConIFA was playing its role as a cultural paradiplomacy actor to promote the issues of marginalized people (Utomo, 2019).…”