The Paradox of Cracker Barrel: A Case Study on Place and Placelessness

Abstract

Cracker Barrel restaurants are a fixture across the interstate landscape of the United States. These sites cultivate a strong sense of place through careful theming, generating a distinct sense of rural America and nostalgia for home. At the same time, the uniformity of Cracker Barrel speaks to the notion of placelessness, the eradication of unique local features and homogenization of experience. Cracker Barrel is thus simultaneously placeless and placefull. This research explores this paradoxical notion by utilizing semiotic analyses in an analysis of user-generated Yelp! photos of Cracker Barrels across the country. It is clear from this analysis that the number and wide variety of artifacts vary surprisingly little from store to store. Together, this uniformity and intentional theming help successfully create a sense of place for Cracker Barrel stores as a rural American, 19th century "home-away-from-home."

Ethnicity on the table: A content analysis of online reviews for Syracuse's cuisines

“…Customers who frequent diners value familiarity and homey feelings highly, and these establishments often evoke a sense of home, much like the cookie‐cutter Cracker Barrel restaurants found along U.S highways, which paradoxically offers both a nostalgic sense of familiarity and a consistent experience for patrons in all of its locations (Gregory & Finlayson, 2019; Penman, 2012). The standardized, themed, and heavily controlled atmosphere of Cracker Barrel serves as an excellent example of what diners can provide to their visitors.…”