The paradox of technology in online education during the COVID-19 pandemic: the experiences of safety and security students in a Dutch university

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to reflect on the experiences of safety and security management students, enrolled in an undergraduate course in the Netherlands, and present quantitative data from an online survey that aimed to explore the factors that have contributed to students’ satisfaction with, and engagement in, online classes during the COVID-19 pandemic. The main findings suggest an interesting paradox of technology, which is worth further exploration in future research. Firstly, students with self perceived higher technological skill levels tend to reject online education more often as they see substantial shortcomings of classes in the way they are administered as compared to the vast available opportunities for real innovation. Secondly, as opposed to democratising education and allowing for custom-made, individualistic education schedules that help less-privileged students, online education can also lead to the displacement of education by income-generating activities altogether. Lastly, as much as technology allowed universities during the COVID-19 pandemic to continue with education, the transition to the environment, which is defined by highly interactive and engaging potential, may in fact be a net contributor to the feelings of social isolation, digital educational inequality and tension around commercialisation in higher education.

Retrenchment in Higher Education

“…Fortunately for Bemidji State University, the Accountancy program was fully online before the COVID-19 pandemic. Matczak, et al, (2023) report students tend to discard online education as they see significant limitations of class administration; online education can result in shift of education related to revenue-production; and the change to the online system influenced an increase in social separation and learning transformations. Bughrara, et al, (2023) determined that several learning adjustments occurred as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, such as video conferencing tools, that can be exploited in a post-pandemic world.…”