Using critical race theory (Taylor, Gillborn, & Ladson-Billings, 2009), AsianCrit (Chang, 1993), and epistemological racism (Scheurich & Young, 1997) as conceptual frameworks, I describe my experiences teaching elementary literacy methods courses and interacting with White preservice teachers, administrators, and faculty in two remote, traditionally homogeneous U.S. universities. The findings show that many White undergraduate students judged my English language use and racial characteristics, and resisted my professorial expertise. The university administration often placed me in contentious situations that perpetuated small town conservative values and White superiority over me when student complaints surfaced. Later, when better relationships were established with the students, drastically different interactional dynamics took place. Implications included endeavors: (a) to promote diversity in academia and share lessons learned for the benefit of (women) faculty of color, teacher education programs, and university communities; (b) to amend student evaluations from being one of major factors for determining diverse faculty's tenure and promotion because they are not always based on merit, but more often executed from race and gender stereotypes and xenophobia; and (c) to change and modify the current university policy and practices so that university communities and institutions join in concerted efforts to move racial discussion forward.