The mode of binding of a ketonic substrate, which is an analogue of esters in which the 0 of the scissile bond is replaced by CH2, to carboxypeptidase A is similar to that of Gly-Tyr. The site is Si, with the side chain in the pocket of the enzyme, the carboxylate salt-linked to , and the carbonyl group bound to Zn. Thus, esters are probably cleaved at the peptide cleavage site, although not necessanly with the same rate-controlling step or by the same detailed mechanism. The large differences found between the behavior of the enzyme in solution and in one crystalline phase do not apply to a different crystalline phase. For those enzymes for which x-ray diffraction studies have been made on the three-dimensional structures of complexes with ligands, a new level of mechanistic questions arises, related to the detailed succession of binding and catalytic steps. The structures of the long-lived complexes of Gly-Tyr, Phe-GlyPhe-Gly, and other ligands with carboxypeptidase A, for example, along with a wealth of other chemical evidence, have led to detailed proposals (1-4) for the mechanisms of cleavage of peptides and esters. The principle of charge neutrality has been used to treat the general acid-base catalyzed or, alternatively, nucleophilic, first step, and to discuss possible deacylation steps (5).In this paper, the relationship between structural studies and more recent biochemical studies is discussed, with emphasis on the ambiguities in the mechanisms of action of this enzyme.Mechanistic deductions using x-ray results Hydrolytic cleavage of the COOH-terminal peptide bond of the substrate involves nucleophilic attack at the carbonyl carbon and electrophilic attack at the amide NH of this bond. Candidates for nucleophilic attack are Glu-270 to form an anhydride, Glu-270-promoted attack by H20, or (with considerable substrate distortion) a Zn-bound H20 or OH-which is not present in the initial complexes of the x-ray diffraction studies. Candidates for proton donation are Tyr-248 or, less likely, H20. The Zn binds to the carbonyl oxygen of these substrates and initially serves to polarize this C=O bond. If an anhydride is formed, deacylation could occur by attack of Zn-bound water or hydroxyl ion (3,5).The productive binding site S1 places the COOH-terminal side chain in a pocket of the enzyme and binds the substrate's COOH-terminal carboxylate group by two hydrogen bonds to Arg-145 (Fig. 1). Extension of this site shows Arg-127 (SI) 4 A away from Arg-145 and Arg-71 (S2) an additional 4 A away near . This last region may be a recognition site initiating a sliding mechanism for movement of substrate into the pocket (6, 7) and is probably the site of kinetic anomalies for N-acyl-dipeptides (1). The extended binding site is five amino acids in length (8, 9), and it is known that longer substrates do not show these kinetic anomalies (8, 9).The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U. S...