The policy implementation gap of school oral health programmes in Tshwane, South Africa: a qualitative case study

Abstract

Background: School going children across the world continue to experience high levels of untreated dental diseases. The South African Oral Health policy documents present measures to address the oral health needs of children in school settings, yet the burden of oral disease in the country is over 50% among primary school children. Methods: Our study therefore sought to assess the implementation of school oral health programmes in Tshwane in line with policy recommendations using the Walt & Gilson policy analysis triangle. A qualitative explanatory case study was undertaken using a combination of data from direct observations and interviews. The case analysis involved assessing the processes of providing school oral health programmes that were offered at 10 schools in Tshwane. The measuring tools included process maps and an interview guide. Results: The results found that policy implementation was affected by poor prior planning, inadequate resources, poor school infrastructure and lack of support from key stakeholders. Furthermore, inconsistencies in policy interpretation by management, coupled with the fact that the oral hygienists were not conversant with the policy hampered delivery of the policy content. The variations in policy implementation observed were often at the discretion of the oral hygienist in response to contextual challenges. Conclusion: There was policy and practice misalignment and variations in the processes of implementing oral health programmes across the 10 schools. Hence regular monitoring, evaluation and root cause analysis is recommended for such programmes in order to make informed decisions on contextually relevant and standardised programme modifications.

Involvement of high school teachers in Health Promoting School program in selected township, Yangon Region, Myanmar: A cross-sectional mixed methods study

“…In this study, insufficient materials and human resources, time constraints, incompetence of the teachers, poor cooperation of school health partnerships, insufficient awareness of parents, low family economic status were the barriers of the school teachers while involving in the HPS program. The contextual challenges including limited resources and inadequate infrastructure should be informed decision-making processes of how and what activities could be offered [ 68 ]. A qualitative study done in elementary schools from a school district in the Midwestern United States presented that lack of time due to increasing academic demands, lack of desire to play, peer pressure (especially in girls) not to be active and lack of space and equipment impacted the ability of students in physical activity [ 69 ].…”

Implementation fidelity of school oral health programs at a District in South Africa

“…The implications of this study are that, in as much as the hygienists covered a high number of children for the purposes of meeting their annual performance targets, they compromised on the program content and levels of fidelity [33]. This negatively impacts on the effectiveness of school programs in controlling the decay burden [6].…”

The proposed need for integrated maternal and child oral health policy: A case of South Africa

“…Primary health care (PHC) revitalisation is critical to South Africa's ongoing health reforms as it serves as a platform for service delivery, the facilitation of health promotion, illness prevention, and a first point of entry into the healthcare sector (39). Additionally, initiatives such as the universal health coverage namely the National Health Insurance (NHI) Bill aim to improve the South Africa's ailing healthcare system by increasing access and reducing inequalities.…”