The potential of narrative analysis for HPE research: Highlighting five analytic lenses

Abstract

Context Health professions education (HPE) has increasingly turned to qualitative methodology to address a number of the field's difficult research problems. While several different methodologies have been widely accepted and used in HPE research (e.g., Grounded Theory), others remain largely unknown. In this methodology paper, we discuss the value of narrative analysis (NA) as a set of analytic approaches that offer several lenses that can support HPE scholars' research. Methods After briefly discussing the ‘narrative turn’ in research, we highlight five NA lenses: holistic, situated, linguistic, agentive and sequential. We explore what each lens can offer HPE scholars—highlighting certain aspects of the data—and how each lens is limited—obscuring other aspects. To support these observations, we offer an example of each lens from contemporary HPE scholarship. The manuscript also describes methods that can be employed in NA research and offers two different typologies of NA methods that can be used to access these lenses. Conclusions We conclude with a discussion of how different analytic methods can be used to harness each of the lenses. We urge the deliberate selection and use of NA methods and point to the inherent partiality of any NA approach. Reflecting on our position as narrative scholars, we acknowledge how our own lenses illuminate some areas and conceal others as we tell the story of NA. In conclusion, we invite other researchers to benefit from the potential NA promises.

Counternarratives that Illuminate Faculty Agency: A Longitudinal Qualitative Study of Physician Educators in Academic Medicine

“…We drew upon a holistic lens from narrative analysis, a lens that "preserves the status of a story as a complex and integrated unit" (Konopasky et al, 2021, p 1370). By honoring the entirety of each participant's stored experience (Konopasky et al, 2021;Polkinghorne, 1995), this holistic lens also privileged the longitudinal nature of our data.…”

‘Just pretending’: Narratives of professional identity transitions in internal medicine

“…Narrative analysis can provide a unique opportunity to explore the negotiation of identity transitions and its potential in health professions education research has been emphasised. 34 It provides a perspective on how narrative is delivered by a speaker, which can be missed when focussing solely on the content of what is said. 31 It allows us to analyse identity claims and performances 1 and a narrator's sense of agency.…”

“…34 For example, the use of pronouns or tense are functional linguistic tools that can be analysed and could provide insight to narrator's identity and identity work. 34,45 Agency can be explored through narrative analysis in considering how the narrator positions themselves. 34 For example, assessing the function of words, generalised nouns, the use of active or passive voice, and agency mitigation strategies whereby narrators use verbs of obligation to highlight low agency.…”

Competency Levels of Physical Therapists at the Health Institutions: A Cross Sectional Survey

“…Evaluation of the clinical competency takes into account the professional performance during interaction with the patient, involving clinical reasoning applied to decision-making, and conceptual commands necessary to provide health services, teamwork, communication, and professionalism. Konopasky et al (28) stated that the ability to communicate clinical reasoning is a key aspect of demonstrating accountability in clinical practice, they added that in the face of complex, ambiguous, and changing contexts, new graduates need to develop tolerance of ambiguity and a reflexive understanding of practice professional work.…”