The Practice and Challenges of Implementing Critical Thinking Skills in Efl Teachers Questioning Behavior

Abstract

The development of critical thinking is closely related to the questions asked by teachers as the teachers higher-order questions are cognitively demanding to promote students critical thinking. The purposes of this study are to investigate how critical thinking was implemented in EFL teachers questions in the classroom and the challenges faced by EFL teachers in integrating critical thinking questions. In addition, this study also investigated students reasons for non-response to particular questions asked by teachers. Applying mixed-method research design, the data were collected from classroom observation, interview, questionnaire and documentations. The research participants were two English teachers and 229 number of students of year 8. The results showed that the most dominant questions asked by the two English teachers were in Lower-order questions (78,8%), while the Higher-order questions were only (21,2%) questions. Second, the challenges faced by teachers were students intelligence has yet to reach the level of higher-order thinking, unconducive-classroom environment, teachers creativity itself, parental involvement and students lack of vocabulary. Third, dealing with the reason for students non-response in particular questions asked by teachers, there were some reasons, such as students are afraid of making mistakes, they could not put ideas into words, and lack of vocabularies. In conclusion, the teachers faced various challenges in implementing critical thinking questions in the classroom.

A comparative study of critical reading abilities among students in Malaysia and Vietnam: Insights from PISA-based assessment

“…It involves active cognitive processes and holds educational significance. Critical reading skills empower students to analyze, synthesize, and assess written content, fostering critical thinking abilities alongside enhanced comprehension (Hidayati et al, 2020). Initial instruction in critical reading encourages students to identify causal connections, evaluate textual relationships, and adopt a fundamental approach to texts.…”

On Discussing the Application of Language Education Theories in Teachers’ Questioning Practice in EFL Classrooms

“…Zainudin et al [31] studied EFL teachers' questions and the challenges in integrating critical thinking questions in a recent study carried out in Indonesia. The study further proposes the reasons behind why most dominant questions asked by the involved English teacher participants are lower-order or lower level questions, thus justifies the importance of the difficulty level set by the questions to just meet students' ZPD.…”

Which noncognitive features provide more information about reading performance? A data-mining approach to big educational data

“…Reading is one of the most important and complex functions of the human brain. It plays a wide range of roles in daily life, from simple written communication activities to high-level cognitive activities such as critical thinking (Hidayati et al, 2020; OECD, 2019a). As is known, reading performance is the major pillar for understanding and solving problems in all other academic domains.…”