The prevalence of depression and anxiety disorders in indigenous people of the Americas: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

Indigenous populations are considered at higher risk of psychiatric disorder but many studies do not include direct comparisons with similar non-Indigenous controls. We undertook a meta-analysis of studies that compared the prevalence of depression and anxiety disorders in Indigenous populations in the Americas with those of non-Indigenous groups with similar socio-demographic features (Registration number: CRD42015025854). A systematic search of PubMed, Medline, PsycInfo, PsycArticles, ScienceDirect, EMBASE, and article bibliographies was performed. We included comparisons of lifetime rates and prevalence of up to 12 months. We found 19 studies (n =250, 959) from Latin America, Canada and the US. There were no differences between Indigenous and similar non-Indigenous groups in the 12-month prevalence of depressive, generalised anxiety and panic disorders. However, Indigenous people were at greater risk of PTSD. For lifetime prevalence, rates of generalised anxiety, panic and all the depressive disorders were significantly lower in Indigenous participants, whilst PTSD (on adjusted analyses) and social phobia were significantly higher.Results were similar for sub-analyses of Latin America, Canada and the US, and sensitivity analyses by study quality or setting (e.g. health, community etc.). Risk factors for psychiatric illness may therefore be a complex interaction of biological, educational, economic and socio-cultural factors that may vary between disorders. Accordingly, interventions should reflect that the association between disadvantage and psychiatric illness is rarely due to one factor. However, it is also possible that assessment tools don't accurately measure psychiatric symptoms in Indigenous populations and that further cross-cultural validation of diagnostic instruments may be needed too.

Do Norwegian Sami and non-indigenous individuals understand questions about mental health similarly? A SAMINOR 2 study

“…Mainly based on clinical interviews, no differences in the 12-month prevalence rates of mental distress appeared. However, indigenous groups were at higher risk of PTSD [14]. Social origins of mental health problems in aboriginal peoples relate to cultural discontinuity and oppression [15].…”

Evaluation of existing experimental evidence for treatment of depression in indigenous populations: A systematic review

“…According to the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, there are 70 countries with approximately 300 million Indigenous people who live and retain distinct languages, culture, and beliefs (Hall & Patrinos, 2012). However, a recently published systematic review and meta-analysis (Kisely et al, 2017) found that the rates of depressive disorders were not higher among the Indigenous people of the Americas, compared to non-Indigenous groups. Existing studies rarely include Indigenous controls to allow prevalence comparisons.…”

“…Existing studies rarely include Indigenous controls to allow prevalence comparisons. However, a recently published systematic review and meta-analysis (Kisely et al, 2017) found that the rates of depressive disorders were not higher among the Indigenous people of the Americas, compared to non-Indigenous groups. The study's results have to be considered with caution due to limitations such as a possible lack of accuracy when measuring the symptoms of depression with diagnostic tools not validated for use in Indigenous populations.…”

Unravelling the complexities of inequalities in mental healthcare and outcomes for cultural and linguistic minorities

“…A recent meta-analysis covered 19 studies conducted in the Americas, all but three of which came from North America. 4 Of these, ten studies were from the United States and six from Canada. For inclusion in the review, studies had to have data on similar controls.…”