The Promise of MOOCs Revisited? Demographics of Learners Preparing for University

Abstract

This paper leverages cluster analysis to provide insight into how traditionally underrepresented learners engage with entry-level massive open online courses (MOOCs) intended to lower the barrier to university enrolment, produced by a major research university in the United States. From an initial sample of 260,239 learners, we cluster analyze a subset of data from 29,083 participants who submitted an assignment in one of nine entry-level MOOC courses. Manhattan distance and Gower distance measures are computed based on engagement, achievement, and demographic data. To our knowledge, this marks one of the first such uses of Gower distance to cluster mixed-variable data to explore fairness and equity in the MOOC literature. The clusters are derived from CLARA and PAM algorithms, enriched by demographic data, with a particular focus on education level, as well as approximated socioeconomic status (SES) for a smaller subset of learners. Results indicate that learners without a college degree are more likely to be high-performing compared to college-educated learners. Learners from lower SES backgrounds are just as likely to be successful as learners from middle and higher SES backgrounds. While MOOCs have struggled to improve access to learning, more fair and equitable outcomes for traditionally underrepresented learners are possible.

Visions of a Discipline: Analyzing Introductory AI Courses on YouTube

“…MOOCs are closely related to the YouTube education videos we study, and both are purported to provide an avenue of education that is more accessible than traditional universities. However, it is contested whether and to what extent MOOCs do democratize education [25,41,51,76], though work has found that learners who do not have a college degree are more likely to do better on a MOOC than learners with a college degree [63,64]. MOOCs enrollment is often motivated for career building rather than knowledge building [91], and they are typically on a far shorter time scale than a university degree.…”

Clustering Analysis of Admission of New Students Using K-Means Clustering and K-Medoids Algorithms to Increase Campus Marketing Potential

“…The Promise of MOOCs Revisited? Demographics of Learners Preparing for University [28]. From an initial sample of 260,239 learners, we cluster analyze a subset of data from 29,083 participants who submitted an assignment in one of nine entry-level MOOC courses.…”

Aligning the Goals of Learning Analytics with its Research Scholarship

“…Recent work attempts to fill this gap. Research that examines differences in procrastination behaviour (Sabnis et al, 2022), engagement with LA dashboards , and specific analysis of how demographic subgroups persist in open learning environments (Meaney & Fikes, 2023;Nguyen et al, 2020), have all explicitly collected relevant demographic variables and used them to analyze equity gaps along educational, racial, and socioeconomic lines, among others. More work along these lines is needed.…”