Cetotheriids are a once diverse clade of baleen whales with a rich fossil record across the entire Northern Hemisphere, except the Mediterranean Basin. Here, we describe a partial mandible from the upper Miocene Arenaria di Ponsano Formation exposed near Pisa (Tuscany, Italy), which unequivocally represents a cetotheriid based on its low, broadly triangular coronoid process, obliquely oriented condyle, deeply excavated subcondylar furrow, and posteriorly elongated angular process. Our new specimen highlights the apparent rarity of this family in the Mediterranean, which may reflect competition with ecologically similar grey whales. The latter, in turn, may explain the geographical isolation and disparate anatomy of the seemingly endemic Paratethyan cetotheriines.