The Quality of Insurance Intermediary Services - Empirical Evidence for Germany

Abstract

Insurance intermediaries help consumers to economize on information and transaction costs in insurance markets. However, competing insurance intermediaries provide heterogeneous services, which are difficult to assess by incompletely informed consumers. Transaction costs economics, search theory and principal agent theory provide arguments on product quality differences between the two main distribution channels in insurance markets (exclusive agents vs. independent intermediaries). The present paper uses a sample of 927 insurance intermediaries in Germany. By performing OLS estimations we test the impact of the different distribution channels, but also of other factors relating to the information processing activities on intermediaries' service quality. Depending on the proxies used for service quality, we find mixed evidence for the "product quality" hypothesis according to which independent intermediaries provide better service quality than exclusive agents. We find that service quality depends also to a large extent on the information gathering and processing activities of the individual intermediaries.

The Influence of Sellers on Contract Choice: Evidence from Flood Insurance

“…Insurers using direct agents have often been compared to insurers using independent agents (see Regan and Tennyson, 2000, and Hilliard, Regan, and Tennyson, 2013, for reviews of the institutional differences), and we find that insurers selling via direct agents sell more excess coverage. Eckardt and Räthke‐Döppner () determine that independent agents provide higher quality information to consumers, and other studies find independent agents to provide higher levels of service and/or better customer satisfaction (e.g., Barrese et al, ; Eckardt, ). Our finding that higher commission rates do not induce independent agents to sell excess coverage seems to align with the conclusions of these previous studies.…”

Who is Changing Health Insurance Coverage? Empirical Evidence on Policyholder Dynamics

“…The literature on intermediation in the insurance industry suggests that brokers may provide better service to policyholders than can be provided by tied agents due to a higher information level (product quality hypothesis; e.g., Trigo‐Gamarra, ; Eckardt and Räthke‐Döppner, ). If the observed lapse decision always results in an advantage for the policyholder, then our empirical results of higher lapse likelihood when the contract is secured through a broker instead of from a tied agent would strongly support the product quality hypothesis.…”

Polski rynek ubezpieczeń na tle kryzysów społeczno-gospodarczych

“…Pośrednicy, z samej istoty swojego istnienia, a nie tylko ze względu na istniejące regulacje prawne, pomagają konsumentom zrozumieć rynek, dlatego firmy ubezpieczeniowe chętnie korzystają z wielu kanałów sprzedaży swoich produktów (agenci, brokerzy) (Eckardt i Räthke-Döppner, 2008). Dywersyfikacja pozwala na dotarcie do każdego segmentu docelowego rynku (Jędrzejczyk i Przybytniowski, 2009).…”