Polyploids, which arise from whole-genome duplication events, have contributed to genome evolution throughout eukaryotes. Among plants, novel features of neopolyploids include traits that can be evolutionarily or agriculturally beneficial, such as increased abiotic stress tolerance. Thus, in addition to being interesting from an evolutionary perspective, genome duplication is also increasingly recognized as a promising crop improvement tool. However, newly formed (neo)polyploids commonly suffer from fertility problems, which have been attributed to abnormal associations among the multiple homologous chromosome copies during meiosis (multivalents). Here, we test the long-standing hypothesis that reducing meiotic cross-over number may be sufficient to limit multivalent formation, favoring diploid-like bivalent associations (cytological diploidization). To do so, we developed
Arabidopsis thaliana
lines with low cross-over rates by combining mutations for
HEI10
and
TAF4b
. Double mutants showed a reduction of ~33% in cross-over numbers in diploids without compromising meiotic stability. Neopolyploids derived from the double mutant show a cross-over rate reduction of about 40% relative to wild-type neotetraploids, and groups of four homologs indeed formed fewer multivalents and more bivalents. However, we also show that the reduction in multivalents comes with the cost of a slightly increased frequency of univalents and that it does not rescue neopolyploid fertility. Thus, while our results do show that reducing cross-over rates can reduce multivalent frequency in neopolyploids, they also emphasize that there are additional factors affecting both meiotic stability and neopolyploid fertility that will need to be considered in solving the neopolyploid fertility challenge.