The Relationship Between Dental Students’ Assessment Ability and Preclinical and Academic Performance in Operative Dentistry

Abstract

Self-assessment is a critical skill for health care professionals. Because these professionals must be lifelong, self-directed learners and self-regulating practitioners, the ability to self-assess is essential for them. The aims of this study were to measure how dental students self-assessed and peer-assessed their performance in preclinical operative procedures and to evaluate any relationship between their assessment ability and preclinical skills or academic performance. The study was conducted from 2015 to 2016. Third-year students at Harvard School of Dental Medicine self-assessed their work on four preclinical practical exams: Class II amalgam preparation, Class II amalgam restoration, Class III composite preparation, and Class III composite restoration. Three faculty members graded the same preparations and restorations. The difference between the students' self-assessment and the mean faculty assessment was calculated as the student-faculty (S-F) gap. An absolute S-F gap was also calculated with absolute values of differences. A total of 71 students completed these practical exams: 36 in the Class of 2016 and 35 in the Class of 2017. All 71 self-assessments for each of the four practical exams were collected for a response rate of 100%. The results showed that the mean S-F gap ranged from 2% to 8%, and the absolute S-F gap ranged from 7% to 12%. Preclinical performance was correlated with self-assessment accuracy. Low-performing students significantly overestimated their self-assessments compared to the rest of the class. High-performing students had more accurate self-assessments and tended to underestimate themselves. Overall, these results showed that the students had room for improving the accuracy of their self-assessments.Dr. Lee is with the

Final year dental students' self‐assessed confidence in general dentistry

“…When analysing group data, some established limitations must be considered. First, weaker students often lack the ability to self‐assess and self‐reflect accurately, tending to overestimate their ability; therefore, malalignment occurs between their perception with that of the educator. Weaker students lack the metacognitive skills to identify gaps in knowledge and incompetencies within themselves and others leading to the poor ability to self‐directed learning.…”

“…Some students may not either be aware or worse, and may not agree that gaps in knowledge exists . Conversely, high achieving students tend to underestimate their self‐assessed competencies . The two differing groups of students (over‐ and underestimation) within‐group analysis may lead to poor correlation between global self‐assessment and external assessment.…”

Comparison between undergraduate dental students’ self-assessment of pre-clinical crown preparation and assessment by two tutors

“…2 Dentists and dental students, in particular, practice largely as self-regulating, solo practitioners, lifelong self-directed learners, and selfregulating practitioners, making self-assessment critical to their success. 3,4 [ E p u b a h e a d o f p r i n t ]…”

Graduating dentists’ perceptions about their professional competence in Finland and Lithuania

“…In our study, competences to perform procedures were self‐assessed by the graduating students, which may be considered a weakness of the study. However, self‐assessment is an important part of learning . Self‐assessment has been defined as an active process of developing an awareness of personal learning objectives .…”

“…Digital self‐assessment has shown to be equivalent to the conventional form of supervision and it may, in particular, help lower‐performing students to improve their assessment ability . In general, low‐performing students tend to overestimate their self‐assessments compared to high‐performing students, who have more realistic or even underestimated self‐assessments . Besides self‐assessment, experiences of peer assessment and peer feedback have been positive .…”